Hubbard Investments, Inc., Appellant(s), v. Brevard County, Florida, Thirrel A. Altman, Jr., Individually and as Trustee of the Thirrel A. Altman, Sr. Trust U/T/D March 16, 2001, Daniel Hasratian and Karine Melkoumian, Appellee(s).
|
5D2023-2763
|
2023-09-07
|
Closed
|
|
Classification |
NOA Non Final - Circuit Civil - Other
|
Court |
5th District Court of Appeal
|
Originating Court |
Circuit Court for the Eighteenth Judicial Circuit, Brevard County
2023-CA-015474
|
Parties
Name |
HUBBARD INVESTMENTS, INC.
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
Representations |
Blake H. Gaylord
|
|
Name |
Thirrel A. Altman, Sr. Trust U/T/D March 16, 2001
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Thirrel A. Altman, Jr.
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Daniel Hasratian
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Karine Melkoumian
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Hon. Dale Curt Jacobus
|
Role |
Judge/Judicial Officer
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Clerk Brevard
|
Role |
Lower Tribunal Clerk
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Brevard County, Florida
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
Representations |
Laura K. Wendell, Lindsay Behnke, Alicia Gonzalez, Justin E. Caron, Edgar Lopez
|
|
Docket Entries
Docket Date |
2024-10-28
|
Type |
Mandate
|
Subtype |
Mandate
|
Description |
Mandate
|
View |
View File
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-10-28
|
Type |
Misc. Events
|
Subtype |
West Publishing
|
Description |
West Publishing
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-10-07
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Motion For Attorney's Fees
|
Description |
Order on Motion For Attorney's Fees
|
View |
View File
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-10-04
|
Type |
Disposition by Opinion
|
Subtype |
Affirmed
|
Description |
PER CURIAM AFFIRMED; JUDGE MACIVER DISSENTS WITH OPINION
|
View |
View File
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-03-13
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice
|
Description |
NOTICE OF PANEL ASSIGNMENT
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-02-15
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Reply Brief
|
Description |
Appellant's Reply Brief
|
On Behalf Of |
Hubbard Investments, Inc.
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-01-22
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Answer Brief
|
Description |
Appellee's Answer Brief ~ FOR AE, BREVARD COUNTY
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-01-10
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
|
Description |
Order Grant EOT for Answer Brief ~ ANSWER BRF BY 1/22; ABSENT EXTENUATING CIRCUMSTANCES, ADDITIONAL EXTENSIONS OF TIME WILL BE DENIED.
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-01-05
|
Type |
Motions Extensions
|
Subtype |
Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
|
Description |
Mot. for Extensio of time to file Answer Brief
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-12-05
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Answer Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Answer Brief ~ TO 1/12
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-11-08
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Answer Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Answer Brief ~ TO 12/13
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-10-25
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ TO MOTION TO TAX APPELLATE ATTORNEYS' FEES
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-10-20
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Appendix
|
Description |
Appendix for Initial Brief
|
On Behalf Of |
Hubbard Investments, Inc.
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-10-18
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order
|
Description |
Miscellaneous Order ~ AA W/IN 5 DYS FILE APX TO IB
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-10-16
|
Type |
Motions Relating to Attorney Fees/Costs
|
Subtype |
Motion For Attorney's Fees
|
Description |
Motion For Cost To Be Taxed
|
On Behalf Of |
Hubbard Investments, Inc.
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-10-13
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Initial Brief
|
Description |
Initial Brief on Merits
|
On Behalf Of |
Hubbard Investments, Inc.
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-29
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order to Show Cause
|
Description |
Order to Show Cause - Filing Fee ~ W/I 10 DAYS
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-29
|
Type |
Misc. Events
|
Subtype |
Case Filing Fee Paid through Portal
|
Description |
CASE FILING FEE PAID THROUGH PORTAL
|
On Behalf Of |
Hubbard Investments, Inc.
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-28
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order Discharging Show Cause Order
|
Description |
ORD-Discharging Show Cause
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-27
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ PER 9/22 ORDER
|
On Behalf Of |
Hubbard Investments, Inc.
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-27
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Amended Notice of Appeal
|
Description |
Amended Notice of Appeal
|
On Behalf Of |
Hubbard Investments, Inc.
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-22
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order to Show Cause
|
Description |
Order - Show Cause for failure to file amended NOA ~ W/I 10 DAYS
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-18
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order to Travel Together
|
Description |
ORD-Grant Traveling Together ~ CASE NUMBER'S 5D23-2717 AND 5D23-2763 WILL TRAVEL TOGETHER; ASSIGNED TO SAME PANEL; IB/APX BY 10/16...
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-15
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Appearance
|
Description |
Notice of Appearance
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-14
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ PER 9/8 ORDER - JOINT RESPONSE
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-11
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Appearance
|
Description |
Notice of Appearance
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-08
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Amended/Additional Filing(s) Needed
|
Description |
ORD-AA to File Amended NOA ~ AA W/IN 10 DYS FILE AMENDED NOA; PARTIES W/IN 10 DYS RE: CONSOLIDATION/TRAVEL 5D23-2717 AND 5D23-2763
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-07
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Filing Fee
|
Description |
Order to pay filing fee - Civil appeal (300)
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-07
|
Type |
Letter
|
Subtype |
Acknowledgment Letter
|
Description |
Acknowledgement Letter 1
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-07
|
Type |
Misc. Events
|
Subtype |
Fee Status
|
Description |
FP:Fee Paid Through Portal
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-07
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Appeal
|
Description |
Notice of Appeal Filed ~ FILED BELOW 8/31/23
|
On Behalf Of |
Hubbard Investments, Inc.
|
|
|
Thirrel A. Altman, Jr., Individually and as Trustee of the Thirrel A. Altman, Sr. Trust U/T/D March 16, 2001, Daniel Hasratian and Karine Melkoumian, Appellant(s), v. Brevard County, Florida and Hubbard Investments, Inc., Appellee(s).
|
5D2023-2717
|
2023-09-01
|
Closed
|
|
Classification |
NOA Non Final - Circuit Civil - Other
|
Court |
5th District Court of Appeal
|
Originating Court |
Circuit Court for the Eighteenth Judicial Circuit, Brevard County
2023-CA-015474
|
Parties
Name |
Karine Melkoumian
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Thirrel A. Altman, Sr. Trust U/T/D March 16, 2001
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Thirrel A. Altman, Jr.
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
Representations |
Edgar Lopez
|
|
Name |
Daniel Hasratian
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
HUBBARD INVESTMENTS, INC.
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Hon. Dale Curt Jacobus
|
Role |
Judge/Judicial Officer
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Clerk Brevard
|
Role |
Lower Tribunal Clerk
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Brevard County, Florida
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
Representations |
Blake H. Gaylord, Laura K. Wendell, Justin E. Caron, Alicia Gonzalez, Lindsay Behnke
|
|
Docket Entries
Docket Date |
2024-10-28
|
Type |
Misc. Events
|
Subtype |
West Publishing
|
Description |
West Publishing
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-10-07
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Motion For Attorney's Fees
|
Description |
Order on Motion For Attorney's Fees
|
View |
View File
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-10-04
|
Type |
Disposition by Opinion
|
Subtype |
Affirmed
|
Description |
PER CURIAM AFFIRMED; JUDGE MACIVER DISSENTS WITH OPINION
|
View |
View File
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-03-13
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice
|
Description |
NOTICE OF PANEL ASSIGNMENT
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-02-13
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Reply Brief
|
Description |
Appellant's Reply Brief
|
On Behalf Of |
Thirrel A. Altman, Jr.
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-01-22
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Answer Brief
|
Description |
Appellee's Answer Brief ~ FOR AE, BREVARD COUNTY
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-01-10
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
|
Description |
Order Grant EOT for Answer Brief ~ ANSWER BRF BY 1/22; ABSENT EXTENUATING CIRCUMSTANCES, ADDITIONAL EXTENSIONS OF TIME WILL BE DENIED.
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-01-05
|
Type |
Motions Extensions
|
Subtype |
Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
|
Description |
Mot. for Extensio of time to file Answer Brief
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-12-05
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Answer Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Answer Brief ~ TO 1/12
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-11-08
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Answer Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Answer Brief ~ TO 12/13
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-10-25
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ TO MOT FOR FEES AND COSTS
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-10-16
|
Type |
Motions Relating to Attorney Fees/Costs
|
Subtype |
Motion For Attorney's Fees
|
Description |
Motion For Fees and Cost
|
On Behalf Of |
Thirrel A. Altman, Jr.
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-10-16
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Initial Brief
|
Description |
Initial Brief on Merits
|
On Behalf Of |
Thirrel A. Altman, Jr.
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-10-13
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Appendix
|
Description |
Appendix for Initial Brief
|
On Behalf Of |
Thirrel A. Altman, Jr.
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-18
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order to Travel Together
|
Description |
ORD-Grant Traveling Together ~ CASE NUMBER'S 5D23-2717 AND 5D23-2763 WILL TRAVEL TOGETHER; ASSIGNED TO SAME PANEL; IB/APX BY 10/16...
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-15
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Appearance
|
Description |
Notice of Appearance
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-14
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ PER 9/8 ORDER - JOINT RESPONSE
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-11
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Appearance
|
Description |
Notice of Appearance
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-08
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Consolidation
|
Description |
ORD-SUA SPONTE RE CONSOLIDATION/TRAVEL ~ PARTIES W/IN 10 DYS RE: 5D23-2717 AND 5D23-2763
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-05
|
Type |
Letter
|
Subtype |
Acknowledgment Letter
|
Description |
Acknowledgement Letter 1
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-05
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Initial Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Initial Brief ~ TO 10/16
|
On Behalf Of |
Thirrel A. Altman, Jr.
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-05
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Filing Fee
|
Description |
Order to pay filing fee - Civil appeal (300)
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-05
|
Type |
Misc. Events
|
Subtype |
Case Filing Fee Paid through Portal
|
Description |
CASE FILING FEE PAID THROUGH PORTAL
|
On Behalf Of |
Thirrel A. Altman, Jr.
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-01
|
Type |
Misc. Events
|
Subtype |
Fee Status
|
Description |
FP:Fee Paid Through Portal
|
|
Docket Date |
2023-09-01
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Appeal
|
Description |
Notice of Appeal Filed ~ FILED BELOW 8/30/23
|
On Behalf Of |
Thirrel A. Altman, Jr.
|
|
Docket Date |
2024-10-28
|
Type |
Mandate
|
Subtype |
Mandate
|
Description |
Mandate
|
View |
View File
|
|
|
HUBBARD INVESTMENTS, INC. VS BREVARD COUNTY, FLORIDA, ALEX B. ALTMAN, ESTATE OF THIRREL A. ALTMAN, SR., ROBERTA M. ALTMAN, THAD ALTMAN, LISA CULLEN, BREVARD COUNTY TAX COLLECTOR, DANIEL HASRATIAN, KARINE MELKOUMIAN, ET AL.
|
5D2019-1888
|
2019-06-26
|
Closed
|
|
Classification |
NOA Non Final - Circuit Civil - Other
|
Court |
5th District Court of Appeal
|
Originating Court |
Circuit Court for the Eighteenth Judicial Circuit, Brevard County
05-2018-CA-055386-X
|
Parties
Name |
HUBBARD INVESTMENTS, INC.
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
Representations |
S. CARY GAYLORD, Blake H. Gaylord
|
|
Name |
Daniel Hasratian
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Karine Melkoumian
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
JANE E. PINTER
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
LISA CULLEN
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
JOHN M. PINTER
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
ROBERTA M. ALTMAN
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
BREVARD COUNTY TAX COLLECTOR
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
THAD ALTMAN
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
ESTATE OF THIRREL A. ALTMAN, SR.
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
MERS, AS NOMINEE FOR TD BANK, N.A.
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Brevard County, Florida
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
Representations |
JAD M. BREWER, CHRISTINE VALLIERE, GORDON H. HARRIS, TRIZIA G. EAVENSON, Edgar Lopez, Howard S. Marks
|
|
Name |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
MERS, AS NOMINEE FOR HSBC BANK USA, N.A.
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Hon. William David Dugan DNU
|
Role |
Judge/Judicial Officer
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Clerk Brevard
|
Role |
Lower Tribunal Clerk
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Docket Entries
Docket Date |
2020-08-03
|
Type |
Record
|
Subtype |
Returned Records
|
Description |
Returned Records ~ NO RECORD EFILED
|
|
Docket Date |
2020-07-10
|
Type |
Disposition by Opinion
|
Subtype |
Reversed
|
Description |
Reversed - Per Curiam Opinion
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-12-13
|
Type |
Misc. Events
|
Subtype |
Miscellaneous Docket Entry
|
Description |
Miscellaneous Docket Entry ~ REQUEST FOR OA
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-12-13
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Reply Brief
|
Description |
Appellant's Reply Brief ~ FOR AAS- ALEX ALTMAN, ROBERTA ALTMAN, THAD ALTMAN, DANIEL HASRATIAN AND KARINE MELKOUMIAN
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-12-12
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Reply Brief
|
Description |
Appellant's Reply Brief ~ FOR AAS- JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER, TRUSTEES OF THE JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER TRUST U/A/D 05/12/08
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-11-04
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Reply Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Reply Brief ~ TO 12/13 (FOR AAS- ALEX ALTMAN, ROBERTA ALTMAN, THAD ALTMAN, DANIEL HASRATIAN AND KARINE MELKOUMIAN)
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-11-01
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Reply Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Reply Brief ~ TO 12/13 (FOR AAS- JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER, TRUSTEES OF THE JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER TRUST U/A/D 05/12/08)
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-10-24
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Answer Brief
|
Description |
Appellee's Answer Brief ~ SEE AMENDED BRIEF
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-12
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ PER 7/3 ORDER
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-09-20
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Answer Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Answer Brief ~ TO 10/24
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-08-29
|
Type |
Motions Relating to Attorney Fees/Costs
|
Subtype |
Motion For Attorney's Fees
|
Description |
Motion For Attorney's Fees ~ FOR MERIT PANEL CONSIDERATION
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-08-29
|
Type |
Motions Relating to Briefs
|
Subtype |
Motion To File Enlarged Brief
|
Description |
Motion To File Enlarged Brief
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-08-28
|
Type |
Motions Relating to Attorney Fees/Costs
|
Subtype |
Motion For Attorney's Fees
|
Description |
Motion For Fees and Cost ~ FOR MERIT PANEL CONSIDERATION
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-08-09
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Answer Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Answer Brief ~ TO 9/20
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-26
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Initial Brief
|
Description |
Initial Brief on Merits ~ FOR AA - HUBBARD INVESTMENTS, INC.
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-25
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Initial Brief
|
Description |
Initial Brief on Merits ~ FOR AAS- ALEX ALTMAN, ROBERTA ALTMAN, THAD ALTMAN, DANIEL HASRATIAN AND KARINE MELKOUMIAN
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-26
|
Type |
Misc. Events
|
Subtype |
Case Filing Fee Paid through Portal
|
Description |
CASE FILING FEE PAID THROUGH PORTAL
|
On Behalf Of |
Hubbard Investments, Inc.
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-12
|
Type |
Record
|
Subtype |
Appendix to Response
|
Description |
Appendix to Response
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-02
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ PER 7/2 ORDER
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-02
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order
|
Description |
Miscellaneous Order ~ AE'S ADVISE IF 19-1888, 19-1839 AND 19-1842 SHOULD TRAVEL TOGETHER
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-01
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ RESPONSE PER ORDER IN 5D19-1839 AND 5D19-1842
|
On Behalf Of |
Hubbard Investments, Inc.
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-27
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Initial Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Initial Brief ~ SEE AMENDED NOTICE
|
On Behalf Of |
Hubbard Investments, Inc.
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-26
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Appeal
|
Description |
Notice of Appeal Filed ~ FILED BELOW 6/21/19
|
On Behalf Of |
Hubbard Investments, Inc.
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-26
|
Type |
Letter
|
Subtype |
Acknowledgment Letter
|
Description |
Acknowledgement Letter 1
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-26
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Filing Fee
|
Description |
Order to pay filing fee - Civil appeal (300)
|
|
|
JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER, AS TRUSTEES OF THE JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER TRUST U/A/D 05/12/08 VS BREVARD COUNTY, FLORIDA, ALEX B. ALTMAN, ESTATE OF THIRREL A. ALTMAN, SR., ROBERTA M. ALTMAN, THAD ALTMAN, LISA CULLEN, BREVARD COUNTY TAX COLLECTOR, DANIEL HASRATIAN, KARINE MELKOUMIAN, ET AL.
|
5D2019-1842
|
2019-06-21
|
Closed
|
|
Classification |
NOA Non Final - Circuit Civil - Other
|
Court |
5th District Court of Appeal
|
Originating Court |
Circuit Court for the Eighteenth Judicial Circuit, Brevard County
05-2018-CA-055386-X
|
Parties
Name |
JOHN M. PINTER
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
Representations |
Howard S. Marks
|
|
Name |
JANE E. PINTER
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Brevard County, Florida
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
Representations |
JAD M. BREWER, Edgar Lopez, S. CARY GAYLORD, TRIZIA G. EAVENSON, Blake H. Gaylord, CHRISTINE VALLIERE, GORDON H. HARRIS
|
|
Name |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Karine Melkoumian
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
THAD ALTMAN
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Daniel Hasratian
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
BREVARD COUNTY TAX COLLECTOR
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
HUBBARD INVESTMENTS, INC.
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
MERS, AS NOMINEE FOR TD BANK, N.A.
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
LISA CULLEN
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
MERS, AS NOMINEE FOR HSBC BANK USA, N.A.
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
ROBERTA M. ALTMAN
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
ESTATE OF THIRREL A. ALTMAN, SR.
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Hon. William David Dugan DNU
|
Role |
Judge/Judicial Officer
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Clerk Brevard
|
Role |
Lower Tribunal Clerk
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Docket Entries
Docket Date |
2019-07-25
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Initial Brief
|
Description |
Initial Brief on Merits ~ FOR AAS- ALEX ALTMAN, ROBERTA ALTMAN, THAD ALTMAN, DANIEL HASRATIAN AND KARINE MELKOUMIAN
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-11-04
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Reply Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Reply Brief ~ TO 12/13 (FOR AAS- ALEX ALTMAN, ROBERTA ALTMAN, THAD ALTMAN, DANIEL HASRATIAN AND KARINE MELKOUMIAN)
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-11-01
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Reply Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Reply Brief ~ TO 12/13 (FOR AAS- JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER, TRUSTEES OF THE JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER TRUST U/A/D 05/12/08)
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-10-24
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Amended Answer Brief
|
Description |
Amended Appellee's Answer Brief
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-09-20
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Answer Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Answer Brief ~ TO 10/24
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-08-29
|
Type |
Motions Relating to Attorney Fees/Costs
|
Subtype |
Motion For Attorney's Fees
|
Description |
Motion For Attorney's Fees ~ FOR MERIT PANEL CONSIDERATION
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-08-29
|
Type |
Motions Relating to Briefs
|
Subtype |
Motion To File Enlarged Brief
|
Description |
Motion To File Enlarged Brief
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-08-28
|
Type |
Motions Relating to Attorney Fees/Costs
|
Subtype |
Motion For Attorney's Fees
|
Description |
Motion For Fees and Cost ~ FOR MERIT PANEL CONSIDERATION
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-08-09
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Answer Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Answer Brief ~ TO 9/20
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-26
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Initial Brief
|
Description |
Initial Brief on Merits ~ FOR AA - HUBBARD INVESTMENTS, INC.
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2020-08-03
|
Type |
Record
|
Subtype |
Returned Records
|
Description |
Returned Records ~ NO RECORD EFILED
|
|
Docket Date |
2020-07-10
|
Type |
Disposition by Opinion
|
Subtype |
Reversed
|
Description |
Reversed - Per Curiam Opinion
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-12-13
|
Type |
Misc. Events
|
Subtype |
Miscellaneous Docket Entry
|
Description |
Miscellaneous Docket Entry ~ REQUEST FOR OA
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-12-13
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Reply Brief
|
Description |
Appellant's Reply Brief ~ FOR AAS- ALEX ALTMAN, ROBERTA ALTMAN, THAD ALTMAN, DANIEL HASRATIAN AND KARINE MELKOUMIAN
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-12-12
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Reply Brief
|
Description |
Appellant's Reply Brief ~ FOR AAS- JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER, TRUSTEES OF THE JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER TRUST U/A/D 05/12/08
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-12
|
Type |
Record
|
Subtype |
Appendix to Response
|
Description |
Appendix to Response
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-12
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ PER 7/3 ORDER
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-02
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ PER 6/25 ORDER
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-28
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Appearance
|
Description |
Notice of Appearance
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-28
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ PER 6/25 ORDER- JOINT RESPONSE
|
On Behalf Of |
JOHN M. PINTER
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-27
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Initial Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Initial Brief ~ TO 7/26
|
On Behalf Of |
JOHN M. PINTER
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-25
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Appearance
|
Description |
Notice of Appearance
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-25
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order
|
Description |
Miscellaneous Order ~ AAS AND AES ADVISE W/IN 10 DAYS IF 19-1839 AND 19-1842 SHOULD TRAVEL TOGETHER
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-25
|
Type |
Letter
|
Subtype |
Acknowledgment Letter
|
Description |
Acknowledgement Letter 1 ~ AMENDED
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-21
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Appeal
|
Description |
Notice of Appeal Filed ~ FILED BELOW 6/21/19
|
On Behalf Of |
JOHN M. PINTER
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-21
|
Type |
Misc. Events
|
Subtype |
Fee Status
|
Description |
FP:Fee Paid Through Portal
|
On Behalf Of |
JOHN M. PINTER
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-21
|
Type |
Letter
|
Subtype |
Acknowledgment Letter
|
Description |
Acknowledgement Letter 1
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-21
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Filing Fee
|
Description |
Order to pay filing fee - Civil appeal (300)
|
|
|
ALEX B. ALTMAN, ROBERTA M. ALTMAN, THAD ALTMAN, DANIEL HASRATIAN, KARINE MELKOUMIAN, JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER AS TRUSTEES OF THE JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER TRUST U/A/D 05/12/08, ET AL. VS BREVARD COUNTY, FLORIDA, ESTATE OF THIRREL A. ALTMAN, SR., LISA CULLEN, AS BREVARD COUNTY TAX COLLECTOR, MERS, AS NOMINEE FOR HSBC BANK USA, N.A., AND MERS AS NOMINEE FOR TD BANK, N.A.
|
5D2019-1839
|
2019-06-21
|
Closed
|
|
Classification |
NOA Non Final - Circuit Civil - Other
|
Court |
5th District Court of Appeal
|
Originating Court |
Circuit Court for the Eighteenth Judicial Circuit, Brevard County
05-2018-CA-055386-XXXX-XX
|
Parties
Name |
HUBBARD INVESTMENTS, INC.
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Daniel Hasratian
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
JOHN M. PINTER
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
JANE E. PINTER
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
Representations |
GORDON H. HARRIS, Sheena A. Thakrar, Blake H. Gaylord, S. CARY GAYLORD, Howard S. Marks, Edgar Lopez, Lisa J. Geiger
|
|
Name |
THAD ALTMAN
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Karine Melkoumian
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
ROBERTA M. ALTMAN
|
Role |
Appellant
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Brevard County, Florida
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
Representations |
TRIZIA G. EAVENSON, CHRISTINE VALLIERE, JAD M. BREWER
|
|
Name |
MERS, AS NOMINEE FOR HSBC BANK USA, N.A.
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
LISA CULLEN
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
ESTATE OF THIRREL A. ALTMAN, SR.
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
MERS, AS NOMINEE FOR TD BANK, N.A.
|
Role |
Appellee
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Hon. William David Dugan DNU
|
Role |
Judge/Judicial Officer
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Name |
Clerk Brevard
|
Role |
Lower Tribunal Clerk
|
Status |
Active
|
|
Docket Entries
Docket Date |
2020-08-03
|
Type |
Record
|
Subtype |
Returned Records
|
Description |
Returned Records ~ NO RECORD EFILED
|
|
Docket Date |
2020-08-03
|
Type |
Mandate
|
Subtype |
Mandate
|
Description |
Mandate
|
|
Docket Date |
2020-07-10
|
Type |
Disposition by Opinion
|
Subtype |
Reversed
|
Description |
Reversed - Per Curiam Opinion
|
|
Docket Date |
2020-07-10
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Motion For Attorney's Fees
|
Description |
Order Granting Attorney's Fees
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-12-16
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order Dispensing with Oral Argument
|
Description |
ORD-DISPENSING ORAL ARGUMENT
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-12-13
|
Type |
Misc. Events
|
Subtype |
Miscellaneous Docket Entry
|
Description |
Miscellaneous Docket Entry ~ REQUEST FOR OA
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-12-13
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Reply Brief
|
Description |
Appellant's Reply Brief ~ FOR AAS- ALEX ALTMAN, ROBERTA ALTMAN, THAD ALTMAN, DANIEL HASRATIAN AND KARINE MELKOUMIAN
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-12-12
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Reply Brief
|
Description |
Appellant's Reply Brief ~ FOR AAS- JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER, TRUSTEES OF THE JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER TRUST U/A/D 05/12/08
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-11-04
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Reply Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Reply Brief ~ TO 12/13 (FOR AAS- ALEX ALTMAN, ROBERTA ALTMAN, THAD ALTMAN, DANIEL HASRATIAN AND KARINE MELKOUMIAN)
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-11-01
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Reply Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Reply Brief ~ TO 12/13 (FOR AAS- JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER, TRUSTEES OF THE JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER TRUST U/A/D 05/12/08)
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-10-24
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Appendix
|
Description |
Appendix for Amended Answer Brief
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-08-29
|
Type |
Motions Relating to Attorney Fees/Costs
|
Subtype |
Motion For Attorney's Fees
|
Description |
Motion For Cost To Be Taxed ~ FOR MERIT PANEL CONSIDERATION
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-09-20
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Answer Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Answer Brief ~ TO 10/24
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-09-06
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Motion To File Enlarged Brief
|
Description |
Order Authorizing Longer Brief ~ AB 80 PAGES MAX
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-08-29
|
Type |
Motions Relating to Briefs
|
Subtype |
Motion To File Enlarged Brief
|
Description |
Motion To File Enlarged Brief
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-08-28
|
Type |
Motions Relating to Attorney Fees/Costs
|
Subtype |
Motion For Attorney's Fees
|
Description |
Motion For Fees and Cost ~ FOR MERIT PANEL CONSIDERATION
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-08-09
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Answer Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Answer Brief ~ TO 9/20
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-26
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Initial Brief
|
Description |
Initial Brief on Merits ~ FOR AA - HUBBARD INVESTMENTS, INC.
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-25
|
Type |
Brief
|
Subtype |
Appendix
|
Description |
Appendix for Initial Brief ~ FOR AAS- JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER, TRUSTEES OF THE JOHN M. PINTER AND JANE E. PINTER TRUST U/A/D 05/12/08
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-25
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Motion To Dismiss
|
Description |
ORD-Denying Motion to Dismiss
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-12
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ PER 7/3 ORDER
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-12
|
Type |
Record
|
Subtype |
Appendix to Response
|
Description |
Appendix to Response
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-10
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Motion to Consolidate
|
Description |
ORD-Granting Consolidation ~ WITH 19-1842 & 19-1888; AAS MAY FILE 1 SINGLE OR 3 SEPARATE IBS W/IN 15 DAYS
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-03
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order to File Response
|
Description |
ORD-To File Response ~ AAS W/IN 10 DAYS- MOT TO DISMISS
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-03
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ PER 6/25 ORDER (FOR AE, BREVARD COUNTY)
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-02
|
Type |
Motions Other
|
Subtype |
Motion To Dismiss
|
Description |
Motion To Dismiss
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-02
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ PER 6/25 ORDER (FOR AE, HUBBARD INVESTMENTS, INC.)
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-07-02
|
Type |
Record
|
Subtype |
Appendix
|
Description |
Appendix ~ TO MOT DISM
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-28
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Appearance
|
Description |
Notice of Appearance
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-28
|
Type |
Response
|
Subtype |
Response
|
Description |
RESPONSE ~ PER 6/25 ORDER- JOINT RESPONSE
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-27
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Miscellaneous Motion
|
Description |
Grant Miscellaneous Motion
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-27
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Initial Brief
|
Description |
Notice of Agreed Extension - Initial Brief ~ TO 7/26
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-26
|
Type |
Motions Other
|
Subtype |
Miscellaneous Motion
|
Description |
Miscellaneous Motion ~ TO CORRECT CASE STYLE
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-25
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice
|
Description |
Notice ~ CORRECTION OF CASE STYLE
|
On Behalf Of |
Brevard County, Florida
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-25
|
Type |
Letter
|
Subtype |
Acknowledgment Letter
|
Description |
Acknowledgement Letter 1 ~ AMENDED
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-25
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order
|
Description |
Miscellaneous Order ~ AAS AND AES ADVISE W/IN 10 DAYS IF 19-1839 AND 19-1842 SHOULD TRAVEL TOGETHER
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-24
|
Type |
Misc. Events
|
Subtype |
Case Filing Fee Paid through Portal
|
Description |
CASE FILING FEE PAID THROUGH PORTAL ~ MFC #25090453
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-21
|
Type |
Order
|
Subtype |
Order on Filing Fee
|
Description |
Order to pay filing fee - Civil appeal (300)
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-21
|
Type |
Letter
|
Subtype |
Acknowledgment Letter
|
Description |
Acknowledgement Letter 1
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-21
|
Type |
Notice
|
Subtype |
Notice of Appeal
|
Description |
Notice of Appeal Filed ~ FILED BELOW 6/21/19
|
On Behalf Of |
ALEX B. ALTMAN
|
|
Docket Date |
2019-06-21
|
Type |
Misc. Events
|
Subtype |
Fee Status
|
Description |
FP:Fee Paid Through Portal
|
|
|