Home Page
Counties
Leon
32301
FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.

Company Details

Entity Name:	FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.
Jurisdiction:	FLORIDA
Filing Type:	Domestic Non-Profit
Status:	Active
Date Filed:	27 Feb 1964 (61 years ago)
Document Number:	706910
FEI/EIN Number	590690327
Address:	306 EAST COLLEGE AVENUE, TALLAHASSEE, FL, 32301, US
Mail Address:	306 EAST COLLEGE AVENUE, TALLAHASSEE, FL, 32301, US
ZIP code:	32301
County:	Leon
Place of Formation:	FLORIDA

form 5500

Plan Name

Plan Year

EIN/PN

Received

Sponsor

Total number of participants

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC. 401(K) RETIREMENT PLAN

2020

590690327

2021-08-02

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.

File	View Page
Three-digit plan number (PN)	003
Effective date of plan	1986-01-01
Business code	813000
Sponsor’s telephone number	8502229800
Plan sponsor’s address	306 EAST COLLEGE AVENUE, TALLAHASSE, FL, 32301

Signature of

Role	Plan administrator
Date	2021-08-02
Name of individual signing	SHIRLEY GILKESON
Valid signature	Filed with authorized/valid electronic signature

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INCORPORATED MONEY PURCHASE PLAN

2020

590690327

2021-08-02

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.

File	View Page
Three-digit plan number (PN)	004
Effective date of plan	2001-01-01
Business code	813000
Sponsor’s telephone number	8502229800
Plan sponsor’s address	306 EAST COLLEGE AVENUE, TALLAHASSEE, FL, 32301

Signature of

Role	Plan administrator
Date	2021-08-02
Name of individual signing	SHIRLEY GILKESON
Valid signature	Filed with authorized/valid electronic signature

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC. 401(K) RETIREMENT PLAN

2019

590690327

2020-10-15

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.

File	View Page
Three-digit plan number (PN)	003
Effective date of plan	1986-01-01
Business code	813000
Sponsor’s telephone number	4078416230
Plan sponsor’s address	307 PARK LAKE CIRCLE, ORLANDO, FL, 328030000

Signature of

Role	Plan administrator
Date	2020-10-15
Name of individual signing	KAYE LYNN MATTERN
Valid signature	Filed with authorized/valid electronic signature

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INCORPORATED MONEY PURCHASE PLAN

2019

590690327

2020-10-15

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.

File	View Page
Three-digit plan number (PN)	004
Effective date of plan	2001-01-01
Business code	813000
Sponsor’s telephone number	4078416230
Plan sponsor’s address	307 PARK LAKE CIRCLE, ORLANDO, FL, 328030000

Signature of

Role	Plan administrator
Date	2020-10-15
Name of individual signing	KAYE LYNN MATTERN
Valid signature	Filed with authorized/valid electronic signature

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC. 401(K) RETIREMENT PLAN

2018

590690327

2019-10-11

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.

File	View Page
Three-digit plan number (PN)	003
Effective date of plan	1986-01-01
Business code	813000
Sponsor’s telephone number	4078416230
Plan sponsor’s address	307 PARK LAKE CIRCLE, ORLANDO, FL, 328030000

Signature of

Role	Plan administrator
Date	2019-10-11
Name of individual signing	KAYE LYNN MATTERN
Valid signature	Filed with authorized/valid electronic signature

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INCORPORATED MONEY PURCHASE PLAN

2018

590690327

2019-10-11

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.

File	View Page
Three-digit plan number (PN)	004
Effective date of plan	2001-01-01
Business code	813000
Sponsor’s telephone number	4078416230
Plan sponsor’s address	307 PARK LAKE CIRCLE, ORLANDO, FL, 328030000

Signature of

Role	Plan administrator
Date	2019-10-11
Name of individual signing	KAYE LYNN MATTERN
Valid signature	Filed with authorized/valid electronic signature

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC. 401(K) RETIREMENT PLAN

2017

590690327

2018-07-31

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.

File	View Page
Three-digit plan number (PN)	003
Effective date of plan	1986-01-01
Business code	813000
Sponsor’s telephone number	4078416230
Plan sponsor’s address	307 PARK LAKE CIRCLE, ORLANDO, FL, 328030000

Signature of

Role	Plan administrator
Date	2018-07-31
Name of individual signing	KAYE LYNN MATTERN
Valid signature	Filed with authorized/valid electronic signature

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INCORPORATED MONEY PURCHASE PLAN

2017

590690327

2018-07-31

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.

File	View Page
Three-digit plan number (PN)	004
Effective date of plan	2001-01-01
Business code	813000
Sponsor’s telephone number	4078416230
Plan sponsor’s address	307 PARK LAKE CIRCLE, ORLANDO, FL, 328030000

Signature of

Role	Plan administrator
Date	2018-07-31
Name of individual signing	KAYE LYNN MATTERN
Valid signature	Filed with authorized/valid electronic signature

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC. 401(K) RETIREMENT PLAN

2016

590690327

2017-10-11

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.

File	View Page
Three-digit plan number (PN)	003
Effective date of plan	1986-01-01
Business code	813000
Sponsor’s telephone number	4078416230
Plan sponsor’s address	307 PARK LAKE CIRCLE, ORLANDO, FL, 328030000

Signature of

Role	Plan administrator
Date	2017-10-11
Name of individual signing	KAYE LYNN MATTERN
Valid signature	Filed with authorized/valid electronic signature

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INCORPORATED MONEY PURCHASE PLAN

2016

590690327

2017-10-11

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.

File	View Page
Three-digit plan number (PN)	004
Effective date of plan	2001-01-01
Business code	813000
Sponsor’s telephone number	4078416230
Plan sponsor’s address	307 PARK LAKE CIRCLE, ORLANDO, FL, 328030000

Signature of

Role	Plan administrator
Date	2017-10-11
Name of individual signing	KAYE LYNN MATTERN
Valid signature	Filed with authorized/valid electronic signature

Agent

Name	Role	Address
Mayhew Mary P	Agent	306 EAST COLLEGE AVENUE, TALLAHASSEE, FL, 32301

Boar

Name	Role	Address
Antonucci Larry	Boar	2776 S. Cleveland Ave., Ft. Myers, FL, 33901

Vice Chairman

Name	Role	Address
Haffner Randy	Vice Chairman	900 Hope Way, Altamonte Springs, FL, 32714

Treasurer

Name	Role	Address
Drummond Danielle	Treasurer	1324 Lakeland Hills Blvd, Lakeland, FL, 33805

Chief Financial Officer

Name	Role	Address
Feldman Sheila	Chief Financial Officer	306 EAST COLLEGE AVENUE, TALLAHASSEE, FL, 32301

Secretary

Name	Role	Address
Love Matt	Secretary	3100 SW 62nd Avenue, Miami, FL, 33155

President

Name	Role	Address
Mayhew Mary C	President	306 EAST COLLEGE AVENUE, TALLAHASSEE, FL, 32301

Events

Event Type	Filed Date	Value	Description
AMENDMENT	2007-03-29	No data	No data
AMENDMENT	2005-09-27	No data	No data

Court Cases

Title

Case Number

Docket Date

Status

Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc., Appellant(s) v. Jack Kowalski, Maya Kowalski, and The Estate Of Beata Kowalski, Appellee(s).

2D2024-0382

2024-02-15

Open

Classification	NOA Final - Circuit Civil - Other
Court	2nd District Court of Appeal
Originating Court	Circuit Court for the Twelfth Judicial Circuit, Sarasota County 2018-CA-005321

Parties

Name	Jack Kowalski
Role	Appellee
Status	Active

Name	Maya Kowalski
Role	Appellee
Status	Active
Representations	Kenneth Bradley Bell, Gregory Andrew Anderson, Raymond Thomas Elligett, Jr., Jennifer Courtney Anderson, Amy Stuart Farrior, Michael Grant Tanner, Justin Thomas Delise, Seldon J. Childers

Name	The Estate Of Beata Kowalski
Role	Appellee
Status	Active

Name	American Academy of Pediatrics
Role	Amicus Curiae
Status	Active
Representations	Christine Riley Davis

Name	Children's Hospital Association
Role	Amicus Curiae
Status	Active
Representations	Christine Riley Davis

Name	FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Amicus Curiae
Status	Active
Representations	Andrew Steven Bolin

Name	Hon. Hunter Wyman Carroll
Role	Judge/Judicial Officer
Status	Active

Name	Sarasota Clerk
Role	Lower Tribunal Clerk
Status	Active

Name	JOHNS HOPKINS ALL CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL, INC.
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Carrie J. Williams, Ethen Rubin Shapiro, Chris William Altenbernd, C. Howard Hunter, III, David William Hughes, Patricia Davison Crauwels, Derek M. Stikeleather, M. Peggy Chu, Eleanor Hadden Sills

Docket Entries

Docket Date	2024-10-22
Type	Motions Extensions
Subtype	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Reply Brief
Description	UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE REPLY BRIEF AND UNOPPOSED MOTION TO PERMIT A REPLY BRIEF WITH A HIGHER WORD LIMIT
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.

Docket Date	2024-09-30
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion/Notice Voluntary Dismissal (non-dispositive)
Description	Appellees' notice of voluntary dismissal of cross-appeal is granted, and the cross-appeal is dismissed. The appeal remains pending.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-09-30
Type	Motions Other
Subtype	Motion/Notice Voluntary Dismissal
Description	Motion/Notice Voluntary Dismissal
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2024-09-30
Type	Record
Subtype	Appendix to Answer Brief
Description	Appendix to Answer Brief
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2024-09-30
Type	Brief
Subtype	Answer Brief
Description	Answer Brief
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-09-30
Type	Motions Relating to Oral Argument
Subtype	Motion/Request for Oral Argument
Description	Motion/Request for Oral Argument
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2024-09-30
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2024-09-25
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice
Description	APPELLEES NOTICE OF CHANGE OF RECORD ATTORNEY WITHIN FIRM AND NOTICE OF E-MAIL DESIGNATION
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2024-09-12
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief
Description	The American Academy of Pediatrics and the Children's Hospital Association's motion for leave to file an amicus curiae brief is granted. The amicus curiae brief filed August 12, 2024, is accepted. The Florida Hospital Association's motion for leave to file an amicus curiae brief is granted. The amicus curiae brief attached to the motion for leave is accepted.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-08-22
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Answer Brief
Description	38 DAYS - AB DUE ON 10/11/24
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2024-08-15
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion To Withdraw as Counsel
Description	The motion to withdraw as counsel for Appellees, filed by attorney Nicholas P. Whitney is granted. Attorney Whitney is relieved of further appellate responsibilities. Attorneys Gregory A. Anderson, Jennifer C. Anderson, Raymond T. Elligett, Jr., Amy S. Farrior, Michael G. Tanner, and Kenneth B. Bell remain counsel of record for Appellees.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-08-13
Type	Brief
Subtype	Amicus Curiae Brief
Description	AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS AND THE CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT OF APPELLANT
On Behalf Of	American Academy of Pediatrics
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-08-13
Type	Motions Other
Subtype	Miscellaneous Motion
Description	FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATIONS' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAR AS AMICUS CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF APPELLANT, JOHN HOPKINS ALL CHILDREN HOSPITAL
On Behalf Of	Florida Hospital Association

Docket Date	2024-08-13
Type	Motions Relating to Briefs
Subtype	Motion to File Amicus Curiae Brief
Description	THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS AND THE CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION'S UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMICI CURIAE BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF APPELLANT
On Behalf Of	American Academy of Pediatrics

Docket Date	2024-08-09
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.

Docket Date	2024-08-06
Type	Miscellaneous Document
Subtype	Pay Pro Hac Vice Fee-100
Description	Pay Pro Hac Vice Fee-100
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-08-05
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice
Description	Attorney M. Peggy Chu's motion to appear as a foreign attorney in this proceeding is granted. All parties must serve sponsoring Florida attorney Chris William Altenbernd with all submissions when serving foreign attorney M. Peggy Chu with documents. Pursuant to section 35.22(2)(a), Florida Statutes, if the foreign attorney has not already done so, they shall within ten days remit the statutory fee of $100, which can be paid through the Florida Courts E-Filing Portal or by sending a check payable to the clerk of this court, failing which this order will be vacated and the motion to appear as a foreign attorney will be denied.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-08-02
Type	Record
Subtype	Appendix to Initial Brief
Description	Appendix to Initial Brief
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.

Docket Date	2024-08-02
Type	Brief
Subtype	Initial Brief
Description	Initial Brief
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-07-29
Type	Motions Relating to Parties and Counsel
Subtype	Motion To Withdraw as Counsel
Description	Motion To Withdraw as Counsel
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2024-07-25
Type	Motions Relating to Parties and Counsel
Subtype	Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice
Description	Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice - M. PEGGY CHU
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.

Docket Date	2024-07-23
Type	Record
Subtype	Record on Appeal Unredacted/Not Fully Redacted
Description	CARROLL - PAGES 98,957 - 113,781 REDACTED (VOL. VIII Part 1)
On Behalf Of	Sarasota Clerk

Docket Date	2024-07-11
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
Description	Appellant's "agreed motion to permit the filing of both an initial brief and an answer brief in excess of the word limits provided in rule 9.210(a)(2)(B)" is granted. Appellant may file an initial brief which does not exceed 20,000 words. Appellees may subsequently file an answer brief which does not exceed 20,000 words. Appellant's "agreed motion for extension of time to file initial brief" is granted, and the initial brief shall be served by August 2, 2024.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-02-29
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Cross-Notice Filing Fee Paid through Portal
Description	Cross Notice Filing Fee Paid through Portal
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2024-02-29
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Cross Appeal
Description	Notice of Cross Appeal ~ CERTIFIED
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2024-02-29
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Filing Fee
Description	$295 fee ~ Appellant has filed a notice of cross-appeal. The party submitting this documentshall remit the filing fee of $295, or an order or certificate of insolvency from the lowertribunal, within fifteen days or the submission will be stricken. § 35.22(2)(b), Fla. Stat.

Docket Date	2024-02-21
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2024-06-20
Type	Response
Subtype	Response
Description	NOTICE OF NO OBJECTION
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2024-06-18
Type	Motions Other
Subtype	Miscellaneous Motion
Description	AGREED MOTION TO PERMIT THE FILING OF BOTH AN INITIAL BRIEF AND AN ANSWER BRIEF IN EXCESS OF THE WORD LIMITS PROVIDED IN RULE 9.210(a)(2)(B)
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.

Docket Date	2024-06-18
Type	Motions Extensions
Subtype	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
Description	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.

Docket Date	2024-05-28
Type	Record
Subtype	Exhibits
Description	1 USB *LOCATED IN THE VAULT*
On Behalf Of	Sarasota Clerk

Docket Date	2024-05-23
Type	Record
Subtype	Record on Appeal
Description	CARROLL - PAGES 98,957 - 128,243 REDACTED (VOL. VIII)
On Behalf Of	Sarasota Clerk

Docket Date	2024-02-20
Type	Order
Subtype	Order re Counsel
Description	Order on Foreign Attorney ~ Within twenty days from the date of this order, Attorneys Derek M. Stikeleather and Carrie J. Williams shall move to appear in this court pro hac vice pursuant to Florida Rule of General Practice and Judicial Administration 2.510 or the attorney will be removed from this proceeding.

Docket Date	2024-05-20
Type	Record
Subtype	Record on Appeal
Description	CARROLL - PAGES 92,708 - 98,956 REDACTED (VOL. VII)
On Behalf Of	Sarasota Clerk

Docket Date	2024-04-30
Type	Record
Subtype	Record on Appeal
Description	CARROLL - PAGES 61,777-77,607 REDACTED (VOL. V)
On Behalf Of	Sarasota Clerk

Docket Date	2024-04-26
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion for Extension of Time for Record
Description	The motion for extension of time for record is granted to the extent that the lower tribunal clerk shall transmit the remaining portions of the record within twenty days of the date of this order.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-04-23
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Initial Brief
Description	60 - IB DUE 06/24/2024
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.

Docket Date	2024-04-16
Type	Record
Subtype	Transcript Redacted
Description	10,908 PAGES
On Behalf Of	Sarasota Clerk

Docket Date	2024-04-14
Type	Record
Subtype	Record on Appeal
Description	CARROLL - PAGES 41,611-61,776 REDACTED (VOL. IV)
On Behalf Of	Sarasota Clerk

Docket Date	2024-04-12
Type	Record
Subtype	Record on Appeal
Description	CARROLL - PAGES 31,606 - 41,610 REDACTED (VOL. III)
On Behalf Of	Sarasota Clerk

Docket Date	2024-02-19
Type	Letter
Subtype	Acknowledgment Letter
Description	Acknowledgment Letter 1 ~ AMENDED

Docket Date	2024-04-08
Type	Motions Extensions
Subtype	Motion for Extension of Time for Record
Description	Motion Extension of Time To File Record

Docket Date	2024-03-11
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Pro Hac Vice Fee Paid through Portal
Description	Pro Hac Vice Fee Paid through Portal
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.

Docket Date	2024-02-16
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Case Filing Fee Paid through Portal
Description	Case Filing Fee Paid through Portal
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.

Docket Date	2024-02-16
Type	Order
Subtype	Certificate of Service
Description	c of s; mailing addresses ~ The notice of appeal that initiated this proceeding does not provide mailing addresses for those served with the notice. Appellant shall within five days submit an amended certificate of service that lists current mailing addresses for all entities served with the notice of appeal.

Docket Date	2024-02-16
Type	Letter
Subtype	Acknowledgment Letter
Description	Acknowledgment Letter 1

Docket Date	2024-02-15
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appeal
Description	Notice of Appeal Filed ~ W/ORDER
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.

Docket Date	2024-02-15
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Fee Status
Description	FP:Fee Paid Through Portal

Docket Date	2025-01-09
Type	Order
Subtype	Order to File Response
Description	In an abundance of caution, and upon this court's review of the motion to substitute counsel, the response to the motion to substitute counsel, and the motion to relinquish jurisdiction, appellant shall file a response to the motion to relinquish jurisdiction. Appellant's response shall be filed within five days of the date of this order and shall include whether and how appellees' pending substitution of Childers Law, LLC, for AndersonGlenn, LLP, impacts the proceedings in this court. Further, Gunster, Yoakley & Stewart, P.A., and Buell Elligett Farrior & Faircloth, P.A., may file a response to the motion to relinquish jurisdiction within five days of the date of this order, addressing whether and how the pending substitution impacts the proceedings in this court.
View	View File

Docket Date	2025-01-07
Type	Response
Subtype	Response
Description	CURRENT COUNSEL'S REVISED RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2025-01-07
Type	Motions Other
Subtype	Motion To Relinquish Jurisdiction
Description	MOTION TO RELINQUISH JURISDICTION AND REMAND TO TRIAL COURT
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2025-01-07
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice
Description	NOTICE OF CURRENT COUNSEL'S REVISED RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2024-12-31
Type	Order
Subtype	Order to File Response
Description	Appellees filed a motion to substitute counsel on December 20, 2024. In the motion, appellees indicate that current counsel—Gregory A. Anderson and Jennifer C. Anderson—oppose the substitution. On or before January 6, 2025, Gregory A. Anderson and Jennifer C. Anderson shall file their response, if any, to the motion to substitute.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-12-20
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Miscellaneous Motion
Description	Appellant's unopposed motion for additional time for oral argument is granted. The appellant and the appellees shall each have thirty minutes to present oral argument.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-12-20
Type	Motions Relating to Parties and Counsel
Subtype	Motion For Substitution of Counsel
Description	Motion For Substitution of Counsel
On Behalf Of	Maya Kowalski

Docket Date	2024-12-17
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Oral Argument
Description	This case is provisionally set for oral argument on February 12, 2025, at 09:30 AM, before: Judge Edward C. LaRose, Judge Anthony K. Black, Judge Andrea T. Smith. Oral argument will occur at the Second District Court of Appeal, in the courtroom of the Stetson University College of Law, Tampa Campus, First Floor, 1700 North Tampa Street, Tampa, Florida. The court calendars can be viewed on this court's website at https://2dca.flcourts.gov. Counsel or parties are requested to make their presence known to court personnel by fifteen minutes prior to the time listed above. The panel is subject to change without notice. Should the assigned panel of judges decide that the court will not benefit from oral argument in this proceeding, the attorneys or parties will be notified by order no less than two weeks before the scheduled date. If this is a criminal proceeding where a victim, as defined in article I, section 16(e), Florida Constitution, has invoked their right to notice under article I, section 16(b)(6), the State is directed to provide the victim with notice of this oral argument and of any changes to the scheduled date. Please review the notice regarding oral argument in the Second District Court of Appeal that follows this order.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-12-16
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Oral Argument Date Set
Description	Oral Argument Date Set

Docket Date	2024-12-03
Type	Motions Other
Subtype	Miscellaneous Motion
Description	UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR ADDITIONAL TIME FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.

Docket Date	2024-12-03
Type	Brief
Subtype	Reply Brief
Description	Reply Brief
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-12-03
Type	Motions Relating to Oral Argument
Subtype	Motion/Request for Oral Argument
Description	Motion/Request for Oral Argument
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.

Docket Date	2024-10-31
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Reply Brief
Description	Appellant's "unopposed motion to permit a reply brief with a higher word limit" is granted. Appellant may file a reply brief which does not exceed 6,153 words. Appellant's "unopposed motion for extension of time to file reply brief" is granted, and the reply brief shall be served by December 3, 2024. However, further requests for extension of time are unlikely to receive favorable consideration. Appellees' "notice of change of record attorney within firm and notice of e-mail designation" is stricken. This court granted Attorney Nicholas P. Whitney's motion to withdraw as counsel on August 15, 2024. Attorneys Samantha Lawrence and Connie Stumph have not appeared in this proceeding and are not listed as attorneys of record for the Appellees in this appeal.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-07-10
Type	Record
Subtype	Record on Appeal Unredacted/Not Fully Redacted
Description	CARROLL - PAGES 1-25,889 REDACTED (VOL. I)
On Behalf Of	Sarasota Clerk

Docket Date	2024-03-05
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice
Description	grant pro hac vice and $100 fee ~ Attorney Carrie J. William's motion to appear as a foreign attorney is granted. Allparties must serve sponsoring Florida attorney Chris W. Altenbernd with all submissionswhen serving foreign attorney Carrie J. Williams with documents.Pursuant to section 35.22(2)(a), Florida Statutes, if the foreign attorney has notalready done so, they shall within ten days remit the statutory fee of $100, which can bepaid through the Florida Courts E-Filing Portal or by sending a check payable to theclerk of this court, failing which this order will be vacated and the motion to appear as aforeign attorney will be denied.

Docket Date	2024-03-01
Type	Motions Relating to Parties and Counsel
Subtype	Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice
Description	Motion For Leave To Appear as Foreign Counsel ~ Carrie J. Williams
On Behalf Of	Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, Inc.

Michael Ortiz and Gicensia Rodriguez O/B/O A.O., a minor Appellant(s) v. Florida Birth-Related Neurological Injury Compensation Ass'n, University of South Florida Board of Trustees and Tampa General Hospital, Appellee(s).

1D2023-1591

2023-06-29

Open

Classification	NOA Final - Administrative - Other
Court	1st District Court of Appeal
Originating Court	State Agency 21-3055N

Parties

Name	Michael Ortiz
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Philip Mead Burlington, Adam Richardson, Jack Tobias Cook, Brooke Charlan

Name	Gicensia Rodriguez
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Brooke Charlan, Philip Mead Burlington, Adam Richardson, Jack Tobias Cook

Name	THE A & O COMPANY, CORP.
Role	Appellant
Status	Active

Name	Florida Birth-Related Neurological Injury Compensation Association
Role	Appellee
Status	Active
Representations	Stephen Alexander Ecenia, John Stephen Menton, Tana Storey

Name	University of South Florida Board of Trustees
Role	Appellee
Status	Active
Representations	Chance Lyman

Name	Tampa General Hospital
Role	Appellee
Status	Active
Representations	Dinah Stein

Name	FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Amicus Curiae
Status	Active
Representations	Andrew Steven Bolin

Name	Andrew D. Manko
Role	Judge/Judicial Officer
Status	Active

Name	Julie Hunsaker DOAH
Role	Lower Tribunal Clerk
Status	Active

Docket Entries

Docket Date	2024-06-07
Type	Brief
Subtype	Reply Brief
Description	Reply Brief
On Behalf Of	Michael Ortiz

Docket Date	2024-05-24
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief
Description	Order on Motion for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-05-20
Type	Brief
Subtype	Amicus Curiae Brief
Description	Amicus Curiae Brief
On Behalf Of	FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION

Docket Date	2024-05-16
Type	Motions Other
Subtype	Miscellaneous Motion
Description	Motion for Leave to appear as Amicus Curiae in support of Appellee's, University of South Florida Board of Trustees

Docket Date	2024-05-08
Type	Brief
Subtype	Answer Brief
Description	Answer Brief
On Behalf Of	Tampa General Hospital

Docket Date	2023-12-11
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Answer Brief
Description	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Answer Brief 60 days 02/29/24
On Behalf Of	Florida Birth-Related Neurological Injury Compensation Association

Docket Date	2024-05-08
Type	Motions Relating to Oral Argument
Subtype	Motion/Request for Oral Argument
Description	Motion/Request for Oral Argument
On Behalf Of	Tampa General Hospital

Docket Date	2024-04-26
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion To Withdraw as Counsel
Description	Order on Motion To Withdraw as Counsel
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-04-23
Type	Record
Subtype	Supplemental Record Redacted
Description	Supplemental Record Redacted - 136 pages - Supplement 2

Docket Date	2024-04-11
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion to Supplement Record
Description	Order on Motion to Supplement Record
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-04-08
Type	Motions Extensions
Subtype	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
Description	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
On Behalf Of	University of South Florida Board of Trustees

Docket Date	2024-04-04
Type	Motions Relating to Parties and Counsel
Subtype	Motion To Withdraw as Counsel
Description	Motion To Withdraw as Counsel
On Behalf Of	University of South Florida Board of Trustees

Docket Date	2024-04-03
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	University of South Florida Board of Trustees

Docket Date	2024-04-01
Type	Motions Relating to Records
Subtype	Motion to Supplement Record
Description	Motion to Supplement Record
On Behalf Of	Tampa General Hospital

Docket Date	2024-04-01
Type	Motions Extensions
Subtype	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
Description	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
On Behalf Of	Tampa General Hospital

Docket Date	2024-03-29
Type	Record
Subtype	Index
Description	Appendix to Motion to Supplement
On Behalf Of	Tampa General Hospital

Docket Date	2024-02-28
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time
Description	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - AB 30 days 4/1/24
On Behalf Of	Tampa General Hospital

Docket Date	2024-02-14
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time
Description	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - AB 30 days
On Behalf Of	University of South Florida Board of Trustees

Docket Date	2024-01-16
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time
Description	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - AB 43 days 02/29/24
On Behalf Of	Tampa General Hospital

Docket Date	2023-12-18
Type	Record
Subtype	Supplemental Record Redacted
Description	Supplemental Record Redacted - 68 pages - Supplement 1

Docket Date	2023-12-18
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time
Description	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - AB 60 days 02/9/24
On Behalf Of	University of South Florida Board of Trustees

Docket Date	2023-12-11
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion to Supplement Record
Description	Order on Motion to Supplement Record
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-12-01
Type	Record
Subtype	Appendix
Description	Appendix to Motion to Supplement the Record
On Behalf Of	Gicensia Rodriguez

Docket Date	2023-12-01
Type	Motions Relating to Records
Subtype	Motion to Supplement Record
Description	Motion to Supplement Record
On Behalf Of	Michael Ortiz

Docket Date	2023-12-01
Type	Motions Relating to Oral Argument
Subtype	Motion/Request for Oral Argument
Description	Motion/Request for Oral Argument
On Behalf Of	Michael Ortiz

Docket Date	2023-12-01
Type	Brief
Subtype	Initial Brief
Description	Initial Brief
On Behalf Of	Michael Ortiz

Docket Date	2023-10-31
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Initial Brief
Description	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Initial Brief 30 days/ 12/01/23
On Behalf Of	Gicensia Rodriguez

Docket Date	2023-10-02
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Initial Brief
Description	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Initial Brief 30 days/ IB 11/01/23
On Behalf Of	Gicensia Rodriguez

Docket Date	2023-09-01
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Initial Brief
Description	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - Initial Brief 30 days/ IB 10/02/2023
On Behalf Of	Gicensia Rodriguez

Docket Date	2023-08-21
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Change of Address
Description	Notice of Change of Address
On Behalf Of	Gicensia Rodriguez

Docket Date	2023-07-28
Type	Record
Subtype	Record on Appeal Redacted
Description	Record on Appeal Redacted - 81 pages

Docket Date	2023-07-21
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Docketing Statement
Description	Docketing Statement
On Behalf Of	Gicensia Rodriguez

Docket Date	2023-07-07
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	University of South Florida Board of Trustees

Docket Date	2023-07-06
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	Florida Birth-Related Neurological Injury Compensation Association

Docket Date	2023-06-30
Type	Letter
Subtype	Acknowledgment Letter
Description	Acknowledgment Letter
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-06-30
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appeal
Description	Notice of Appeal-filed by atty.
On Behalf Of	Gicensia Rodriguez

Docket Date	2023-06-29
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appeal
Description	Notice of Appeal

Docket Date	2023-06-29
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Order Appealed
Description	Order Appealed

Docket Date	2024-08-01
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion/Request for Oral Argument
Description	Order on Motion/Request for Oral Argument
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-07-10
Type	Event
Subtype	Fee Paid in Full
Description	Fee Paid in Full
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-07-10
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Filing Fee
Description	Order on Filing Fee
View	View File

Normandy Insurance Company, Zenith Insurance Company, Bridgefield Employers Insurance Company, Bridgefield Casualty Insurance Company, BusinessFirst Insurance Company, and RetailFirst Insurance Company, Appellant(s) v. Department of Financial Services, Division of Workers' Compensation, individually, and on behalf of the Workers' Compensation Three Member Panel, Tallahassee Medical Center, Inc. d/b/a HCA Florida Capital Hospital, West Florida Regional Medical Center, Inc. d/b/a HCA Florida West Hospital, and St. Mary's Medical Center, Inc. d/b/a St. Mary's Medical Center, Safety Net Hospital Alliance of Florida, and Florida Hospital Association, Appellee(s).

1D2023-0834

2023-04-06

Closed

Classification	NOA Final - Administrative - Other
Court	1st District Court of Appeal
Originating Court	Administrative Agency 22-002767RP

Parties

Name	ZENITH INSURANCE COMPANY
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Ralph P. Douglas Jr., David R. Terry

Name	BRIDGEFIELD CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Ralph P. Douglas Jr., David R. Terry

Name	BRIDGEFIELD EMPLOYERS INSURANCE COMPANY
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Ralph P. Douglas Jr., David R. Terry

Name	RETAILFIRST INSURANCE COMPANY
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Ralph P. Douglas Jr., David R. Terry

Name	NORMANDY INSURANCE COMPANY
Role	Appellee
Status	Active
Representations	Thomas Warren Sculco, Shannon McLin

Name	Division of Workers' Compensation
Role	Appellee
Status	Active

Name	TALLAHASSEE MEDICAL CENTER, INC.
Role	Appellee
Status	Active

Name	HCA Florida Capital Hospital
Role	Appellee
Status	Active
Representations	Stephen Alexander Ecenia, Jennifer Forshey Hinson, J. Stephen Menton, Tana Storey

Name	WEST FLORIDA REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, INC.
Role	Appellee
Status	Active

Name	HCA Florida West Hospital
Role	Appellee
Status	Active

Name	ST. MARY'S MEDICAL CENTER, INC.
Role	Appellee
Status	Active
Representations	Michael Joseph Glazer, Shannon Morris

Name	SAFETY NET HOSPITAL ALLIANCE OF FLORIDA, INC.
Role	Appellee
Status	Active
Representations	Virginia C Dailey, Louise R Wilhite-St Laurent, Lindsay Kristen Ervin

Name	FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Appellee
Status	Active
Representations	Virginia C Dailey, Louise R Wilhite-St Laurent, Lindsay Kristen Ervin

Name	Hon. Darren Schwartz
Role	Judge/Judicial Officer
Status	Active

Name	Julie Hunsaker DOAH
Role	Lower Tribunal Clerk
Status	Active

Name	DFS Agency Clerk
Role	Lower Tribunal Clerk
Status	Active

Name	BUSINESSFIRST INSURANCE COMPANY
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Ralph P. Douglas Jr., David R. Terry

Name	Department of Financial Services
Role	Appellee
Status	Active
Representations	Michael B. Dobson, Thomas Nemecek, Keith Charles Humphrey, Gregory M. Munson, Cassidy Perdue, Shelba Sellers

Docket Entries

Docket Date	2023-12-08
Type	Brief
Subtype	Answer Brief
Description	Answer Brief
On Behalf Of	St. Mary's Medical Center, Inc.
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-10-04
Type	Mandate
Subtype	Mandate
Description	Mandate
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-10-04
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	West Publishing
Description	West Publishing

Docket Date	2024-09-16
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion For Attorney's Fees
Description	Order on Motion For Attorney's Fees
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-09-16
Type	Disposition by PCA
Subtype	Affirmed
Description	Affirmed
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-08-02
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Supplemental Authority
Description	Notice of Supplemental Authority
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2024-04-01
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion/Request for Oral Argument
Description	Order on Motion/Request for Oral Argument
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-02-07
Type	Motions Relating to Attorney Fees/Costs
Subtype	Motion For Attorney's Fees
Description	Motion For Attorney's Fees
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2024-02-07
Type	Motions Relating to Oral Argument
Subtype	Motion/Request for Oral Argument
Description	Motion/Request for Oral Argument
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2024-02-07
Type	Brief
Subtype	Reply Brief
Description	Reply Brief
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2024-01-03
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Reply Brief
Description	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Reply Brief
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-12-20
Type	Motions Extensions
Subtype	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Reply Brief
Description	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Reply Brief
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-11-16
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
Description	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-11-02
Type	Motions Extensions
Subtype	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
Description	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
On Behalf Of	Department of Financial Services

Docket Date	2023-11-02
Type	Order
Subtype	Order Striking Filing
Description	Order Striking Filing
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-10-19
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time
Description	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - AB 36 days
On Behalf Of	Department of Financial Services

Docket Date	2023-10-04
Type	Record
Subtype	Appendix to Initial Brief
Description	Appendix to Initial Brief
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-09-26
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
Description	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-09-18
Type	Motions Extensions
Subtype	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
Description	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-08-25
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion For Clarification
Description	Order on Motion For Clarification and Realignment
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-07-29
Type	Response
Subtype	Response
Description	Response to Normandy's motion to review order denying Normandy's motion to stay pending appeal
On Behalf Of	HCA Florida West Hospital

Docket Date	2023-07-25
Type	Post-Disposition Motions
Subtype	Motion For Clarification
Description	Motion For Clarification of 07/13 order
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-07-20
Type	Record
Subtype	Amended Appendix
Description	Amended Appendix
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-07-18
Type	Order
Subtype	Order Striking Filing
Description	Order Striking Filing
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-07-13
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion to Consolidate
Description	Order on Motion to Consolidate
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-07-13
Type	Record
Subtype	Appendix
Description	Appendix to Motion to Review the Order Denying Normanday's Motion to Stay Pending Appeal
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-07-13
Type	Motions Other
Subtype	Miscellaneous Motion
Description	Motion to Review the Order Denying Normanday's Motion to Stay Pending Appeal
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-06-23
Type	Motions Other
Subtype	Miscellaneous Motion
Description	JOINT MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE APPEALS & AMENDED RESPONSE TO APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME
On Behalf Of	Department of Financial Services

Docket Date	2023-06-13
Type	Response
Subtype	Response
Description	Response in Opposition to Motion For Extension of Time
On Behalf Of	St. Mary's Medical Center, Inc.

Docket Date	2023-06-12
Type	Motions Extensions
Subtype	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
Description	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
On Behalf Of	RetailFirst Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-06-05
Type	Record
Subtype	Transcript Unredacted/Not Fully Redacted
Description	Transcript Redacted - 1138 pages

Docket Date	2023-05-23
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	Department of Financial Services

Docket Date	2023-05-03
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	Department of Financial Services
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-05-01
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	HCA Florida Capital Hospital
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-04-28
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Docketing Statement
Description	Docketing Statement
On Behalf Of	RetailFirst Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-04-26
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	St. Mary's Medical Center, Inc.

Docket Date	2023-04-20
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Related Case or Issue
Description	Notice of Related Case or Issue
On Behalf Of	RetailFirst Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-04-18
Type	Event
Subtype	Fee Paid in Full
Description	Fee Paid in Full
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-04-18
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Filing Fee
Description	Order on Filing Fee
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-04-12
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	Department of Financial Services

Docket Date	2023-04-11
Type	Letter
Subtype	Acknowledgment Letter
Description	Acknowledgment Letter
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-04-11
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Order Appealed
Description	Order Appealed

Docket Date	2023-04-11
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appeal
Description	Notice of Appeal-certified
On Behalf Of	Julie Hunsaker DOAH

Docket Date	2023-04-10
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appeal
Description	Notice of Appeal-order appealed attached
On Behalf Of	RetailFirst Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-10-06
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Related Case or Issue
Description	Notice of Related Case or Issue
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-10-04
Type	Brief
Subtype	Initial Brief
Description	Initial Brief
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company
View	View File

1D2023-0830

2023-04-06

Closed

Classification	NOA Final - Administrative - Other
Court	1st District Court of Appeal
Originating Court	Administrative Agency 22-2767RP

Parties

Name	NORMANDY INSURANCE COMPANY
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Thomas Warren Sculco, Shannon McLin, David R. Terry

Name	ZENITH INSURANCE COMPANY
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Ralph P. Douglas Jr.

Name	BRIDGEFIELD EMPLOYERS INSURANCE COMPANY
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Ralph P. Douglas Jr.

Name	BRIDGEFIELD CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Ralph P. Douglas Jr.

Name	Business First Insurance Company
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Ralph P. Douglas Jr.

Name	RETAILFIRST INSURANCE COMPANY
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Ralph P. Douglas Jr.

Name	Department of Financial Services
Role	Appellee
Status	Active
Representations	Gregory M. Munson, Michael B. Dobson, Keith Charles Humphrey, Thomas Nemecek, Shelba Sellers, Cassidy Marie Perdue

Name	Division of Workers' Compensation
Role	Appellee
Status	Active
Representations	Ralph P. Douglas Jr.

Name	TALLAHASSEE MEDICAL CENTER, INC.
Role	Intervenor
Status	Active

Name	HCA Florida Capital Hospital
Role	Intervenor
Status	Active
Representations	Stephen Alexander Ecenia, Jennifer Forshey Hinson

Name	WEST FLORIDA REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, INC.
Role	Intervenor
Status	Active

Name	HCA Florida West Hospital
Role	Intervenor
Status	Active
Representations	Stephen Alexander Ecenia, Jennifer Forshey Hinson

Name	ST. MARY'S MEDICAL CENTER, INC.
Role	Intervenor
Status	Active
Representations	Michael Joseph Glazer, Shannon Morris

Name	SAFETY NET HOSPITAL ALLIANCE OF FLORIDA, INC.
Role	Intervenor
Status	Active
Representations	Virginia Cambre Dailey, Louise R Wilhite-St Laurent, Lindsay Kristen Ervin

Name	FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Intervenor
Status	Active
Representations	Virginia Cambre Dailey, Louise R Wilhite-St Laurent, Lindsay Kristen Ervin

Name	Hon. Darren Schwartz
Role	Judge/Judicial Officer
Status	Active

Name	Julie Hunsaker DOAH
Role	Lower Tribunal Clerk
Status	Active

Docket Entries

Docket Date	2023-07-18
Type	Order
Subtype	Order Striking Filing
Description	Order Striking Filing
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-09-26
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
Description	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-10-04
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	West Publishing
Description	West Publishing

Docket Date	2024-10-04
Type	Mandate
Subtype	Mandate
Description	Mandate
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-09-16
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion For Attorney's Fees
Description	Order on Motion For Attorney's Fees
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-09-16
Type	Disposition by PCA
Subtype	Affirmed
Description	Affirmed
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-08-02
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Supplemental Authority
Description	Notice of Supplemental Authority
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2024-04-01
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion/Request for Oral Argument
Description	Order on Motion/Request for Oral Argument
View	View File

Docket Date	2024-02-07
Type	Motions Relating to Attorney Fees/Costs
Subtype	Motion For Attorney's Fees
Description	Motion For Attorney's Fees
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2024-02-07
Type	Motions Relating to Oral Argument
Subtype	Motion/Request for Oral Argument
Description	Motion/Request for Oral Argument
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2024-02-07
Type	Brief
Subtype	Reply Brief
Description	Reply Brief
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2024-01-03
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Reply Brief
Description	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Reply Brief
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-12-20
Type	Motions Extensions
Subtype	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Reply Brief
Description	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Reply Brief
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-12-08
Type	Brief
Subtype	Answer Brief
Description	Answer Brief
On Behalf Of	St. Mary's Medical Center, Inc.
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-11-16
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
Description	Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-11-02
Type	Motions Extensions
Subtype	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
Description	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Answer Brief
On Behalf Of	Department of Financial Services

Docket Date	2023-11-02
Type	Order
Subtype	Order Striking Filing
Description	Order Striking Filing
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-10-19
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time
Description	Notice of Agreed Extension of Time - AB 36 days
On Behalf Of	Department of Financial Services

Docket Date	2023-10-06
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Related Case or Issue
Description	Notice of Related Case or Issue
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-10-04
Type	Record
Subtype	Appendix to Initial Brief
Description	Appendix to Initial Brief
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-10-04
Type	Brief
Subtype	Initial Brief
Description	Initial Brief
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-09-18
Type	Motions Extensions
Subtype	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
Description	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-08-25
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion For Clarification
Description	Order on Motion For Clarification and Realignment
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-07-29
Type	Response
Subtype	Response
Description	Response to Normandy's motion to review order denying Normandy's motion to stay pending appeal
On Behalf Of	HCA Florida West Hospital

Docket Date	2023-07-25
Type	Post-Disposition Motions
Subtype	Motion For Clarification
Description	Motion For Clarification of 07/13 order
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-07-20
Type	Record
Subtype	Amended Appendix
Description	Amended Appendix
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-07-13
Type	Record
Subtype	Appendix
Description	Appendix to Motion to Review the Order Denying Normanday's Motion to Stay Pending Appeal
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-07-13
Type	Motions Other
Subtype	Miscellaneous Motion
Description	Motion to Review the Order Denying Normanday's Motion to Stay Pending Appeal
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-06-23
Type	Motions Other
Subtype	Miscellaneous Motion
Description	JOINT MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE APPEALS & AMENDED RESPONSE TO APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME
On Behalf Of	Department of Financial Services

Docket Date	2023-06-14
Type	Response
Subtype	Response
Description	Response in Opposition to Motion for Extension of Time to Serve the Initial Brief
On Behalf Of	St. Mary's Medical Center, Inc.

Docket Date	2023-06-13
Type	Motions Extensions
Subtype	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
Description	Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Initial Brief
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-06-07
Type	Record
Subtype	Record on Appeal Redacted
Description	Record on Appeal Redacted - 2868 pages

Docket Date	2023-05-23
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	Department of Financial Services

Docket Date	2023-05-05
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	RetailFirst Insurance Company
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-05-01
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	HCA Florida West Hospital
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-05-01
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Docketing Statement
Description	Docketing Statement
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-04-26
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	St. Mary's Medical Center, Inc.

Docket Date	2023-04-24
Type	Event
Subtype	Fee Paid in Full
Description	Fee Paid in Full
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-04-24
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Filing Fee
Description	Order on Filing Fee
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-04-12
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appearance
Description	Notice of Appearance
On Behalf Of	Department of Financial Services

Docket Date	2023-04-10
Type	Letter
Subtype	Acknowledgment Letter
Description	Acknowledgment Letter
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-04-07
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appeal
Description	Notice of Appeal, certified
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-04-07
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Order Appealed
Description	Order Appealed
On Behalf Of	Julie Hunsaker DOAH

Docket Date	2023-04-06
Type	Notice
Subtype	Notice of Appeal
Description	Notice of Appeal, order attached
On Behalf Of	Normandy Insurance Company

Docket Date	2023-07-13
Type	Order
Subtype	Order on Motion to Consolidate
Description	Order on Motion to Consolidate
View	View File

University of Florida Board of Trustees, et al. , Petitioner(s) v. Laurie Carmody, Respondent(s)

SC2022-0068

2022-01-14

Closed

Classification	Discretionary Review - Notice to Invoke - Certified Direct Conflict
Court	Supreme Court of Florida
Originating Court	1st District Court of Appeal 1D21-634

Parties

Name	University of Florida Board of Trustees
Role	Petitioner
Status	Active
Representations	Francis E. Pierce, III, Christine R. Davis

Name	Shands Hospital
Role	Petitioner
Status	Active

Name	SHANDS TEACHING HOSPITAL & CLINICS, INC.
Role	Petitioner
Status	Active

Name	Laurie Carmody
Role	Respondent
Status	Active
Representations	Adam Richardson, Kennan G. Dandar

Name	FLORIDA JUSTICE ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Respondent
Status	Active
Representations	Dimitrios A. Peteves, Bryan S. Gowdy

Name	American Medical Association
Role	Amicus - Petitioner
Status	Interim
Representations	Mr. Andrew S. Bolin

Name	FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Amicus - Petitioner
Status	Interim
Representations	Mr. Andrew S. Bolin

Name	FLORIDA MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Amicus - Petitioner
Status	Interim
Representations	Mr. Andrew S. Bolin

Name	FLORIDA DEFENSE LAWYERS ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Amicus - Petitioner
Status	Interim
Representations	Kansas R. Gooden, Jessica N. Cochran

Name	Hon. Donna Michelle Keim
Role	Judge/Judicial Officer
Status	Active

Name	Hon. J.K. "Jess" Irby
Role	Lower Tribunal Clerk
Status	Active

Name	1DCA Clerk
Role	Lower Tribunal Clerk
Status	Active

Docket Entries

Docket Date	2023-11-03
Type	Miscellaneous Document
Subtype	Publish Full
Description	Publish Full - Opinion issued July 6, 2023.
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-11-02
Type	Mandate
Subtype	Mandate Issued
Description	Mandate Issued
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-10-12
Type	Disposition
Subtype	Rehearing DY
Description	FSC-OPINION: Petitioners' "Motion for Rehearing" is hereby denied.
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-08-24
Type	Notice
Subtype	Address Change
Description	Notice of Address Change
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-08-03
Type	Response
Subtype	Response
Description	Response to Petitioner's Motion for Rehearing
On Behalf Of	Laurie Carmody
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-07-19
Type	Motion
Subtype	Rehearing
Description	Motion for Rehearing
On Behalf Of	University of Florida Board of Trustees
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-07-06
Type	Disposition
Subtype	Approved
Description	FSC-OPINION: Because the circuit court's allegedly erroneous determination that Dr. DeStephens satisfied the Medical Malpractice Act's presuit requirements does not constitute an "essential departure from the law," certiorari relief is unavailable. We therefore approve the First District's decision below to the extent that it is consistent with our decision here, and we disapprove the Second and Fifth Districts' decisions in Clare and Riggenbach, respectively. It is so ordered.
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-03-14
Type	Notice
Subtype	Supplemental Authority
Description	Notice of Supplemental Authority
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-03-01
Type	Order
Subtype	OA Schedule (Prev Accepted)
Description	ORDER-OA SCHED (PREV ACCEPTED) ~ The Court previously accepted jurisdiction. The Court will hear oral argument at 9:00 a.m., Thursday, April 6, 2023.A maximum of twenty minutes to the side is allowed for the argument, but counsel is expected to use only so much of that time as is necessary.NO CONTINUANCES WILL BE GRANTED EXCEPT UPON A SHOWING OF EXTREME HARDSHIP.
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-02-06
Type	Brief
Subtype	Reply-Merit
Description	REPLY BRIEF-MERITS ~ Reply Brief of Petitioners Unversty of Florda Board of Trustees and Shands Teachng Hosptal and Clinics, d/b/a Shands Hospital
On Behalf Of	University of Florida Board of Trustees
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-01-24
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted and petitioner is allowed to and including February 6, 2023, in which to serve the reply brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.
View	View File

Docket Date	2023-01-24
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Reply Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time
On Behalf Of	University of Florida Board of Trustees
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-12-27
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted and petitioner is allowed to and including January 30, 2023, in which to serve the reply brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-12-27
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Reply Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time
On Behalf Of	University of Florida Board of Trustees
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-12-16
Type	Brief
Subtype	Amicus Curiae Answer
Description	AMICUS CURIAE ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS ~ Amicus Brief of the Florida Justice Association in Support of Respondent
On Behalf Of	Florida Justice Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-12-13
Type	Order
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR ~ The motion for leave to file brief as amicus curiae filed by Florida Justice Association is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of Respondent. The brief by the above referenced amicus curiae shall be served pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.370(c).The motion for extension of time filed in the above case by Florida Justice Association is granted and said amicus curiae is allowed to and including December 19, 2022, in which to serve the amicus brief. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-12-09
Type	Motion
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE ~ Unopposed Motion for Leave for Florida Justice Association to Appear as Amicus Curiae and for Extension of Time
On Behalf Of	Florida Justice Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-11-30
Type	Brief
Subtype	Answer-Merit
Description	ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS ~ Answer Brief of Respondent
On Behalf Of	Laurie Carmody
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-10-31
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Respondent's motion for extension of time is granted, and respondent is allowed to and including November 30, 2022, in which to serve the answer brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.All other times will be extended accordingly.
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-10-31
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Answer Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time
On Behalf Of	Laurie Carmody
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-10-04
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Respondent's motion for extension of time is granted, and respondent is allowed to and including October 31, 2022, in which to serve the answer brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.All other times will be extended accordingly.
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-09-30
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Answer Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time
On Behalf Of	Laurie Carmody
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-09-12
Type	Brief
Subtype	Amicus Curiae Initial
Description	AMICUS CURIAE INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS ~ Amicus Brief of Florida Hospital association, Florida Medical Association and the Litigation Center of the American Medical Association in Support of Petitioners
On Behalf Of	Florida Hospital Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-08-31
Type	Brief
Subtype	Initial-Merit
Description	INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS ~ Initial Brief of Petitioners University of Florida Board of Trustees and Shands Teaching Hospital and Clinics, d/b/a Shands Hospital
On Behalf Of	University of Florida Board of Trustees
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-08-30
Type	Notice
Subtype	Appearance
Description	NOTICE-APPEARANCE
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-07-18
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Initial Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time
On Behalf Of	University of Florida Board of Trustees
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-07-18
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted and petitioner is allowed to and including August 31, 2022, in which to serve the initial brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.All other times will be extended accordingly.
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-07-06
Type	Order
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR ~ The motion for leave to file brief as amici curiae filed by the Florida Hospital Association, Florida Medical Association, and the American Medical Association is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of petitioners. The brief by the above referenced amici curiae shall be served pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.370(c).
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-07-05
Type	Motion
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE ~ FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION AND THE FLORIDA MEDICAL ASSOCIATION AND THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAR AS AMICUS CURIAE IN SUPPORTOF PETITIONERS
On Behalf Of	Florida Hospital Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-06-17
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted and petitioner is allowed to and including July 29, 2022, in which to serve the initial brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.All other times will be extended accordingly.
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-06-15
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Initial Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS) ~ UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME
On Behalf Of	University of Florida Board of Trustees
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-06-14
Type	Record
Subtype	Record/Transcript
Description	RECORD ~ CERTIFIED COPIES OF APPEAL PAPERS * Record filed electronically *
On Behalf Of	1DCA Clerk

Docket Date	2022-06-07
Type	Order
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR ~ The motion for leave to file brief as amicus curiae filed by the Florida Defense Lawyers Association is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of petitioner. The brief by the above referenced amicus curiae shall be served pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.370(c).
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-06-07
Type	Motion
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE ~ FLORIDA DEFENSE LAWYERS ASSOCIATION'SMOTION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAR AS AMICUS CURIAEIN SUPPORT OF PETITIONERS
On Behalf Of	Florida Defense Lawyers Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-05-25
Type	Order
Subtype	Juris Accept/Brief Sched (OA Later Date)
Description	ORDER-JURIS ACCEPT/BRIEF SCHED (OA LATER DATE) ~ The Court accepts jurisdiction of this case. Petitioner's initial brief on the merits must be served on or before June 29, 2022; respondent's answer brief on the merits must be served thirty days after service of petitioner's initial brief on the merits; petitioner's reply brief on the merits must be served thirty days after service of respondent's answer brief on the merits; and respondent's cross-reply brief on the merits, if authorized, must be served thirty days after service of petitioner's reply brief on the merits.The Clerk of the First District Court of Appeal must file the record which must be properly indexed and paginated on or before June 20, 2022. The Clerk may provide the record in the format as currently maintained at the district court, either paper or electronic.As jurisdiction has been accepted in the above cause, any movant who wishes to follow through on a previously-filed Notice of Intent to Appear as Amicus or Amici Curiae must now proceed in compliance with Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.370.Oral argument will be set by separate order. Counsel for the parties will be notified of the oral argument date approximately sixty days prior to oral argument.
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-04-25
Type	Brief
Subtype	Juris Answer
Description	JURIS ANSWER BRIEF ~ Respondent's Answer Brief on Jurisdiction
On Behalf Of	Laurie Carmody
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-03-24
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Juris Brief)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (JURIS BRIEF) ~ AGREED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILERESPONDENT'S BRIEF ON JURISDICTION
On Behalf Of	Laurie Carmody
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-03-24
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Juris Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (JURIS BRIEF-RESPONDENT) ~ Respondent's motion for extension of time is granted and respondent is allowed to and including April 25, 2022, in which to serve the jurisdictional answer brief. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-02-28
Type	Motion
Subtype	Request-Oral Argument
Description	REQUEST-ORAL ARGUMENT ~ REQUEST-ORAL ARGUMENT
On Behalf Of	University of Florida Board of Trustees
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-02-28
Type	Notice
Subtype	Amicus Curiae Intent to Appear
Description	NOTICE-AMICUS CURIAE INTENT TO APPEAR ~ FLORIDA DEFENSE LAWYERS ASSOCIATION'SNOTICE OF INTENT TO APPEAR AS AMICUS CURIAEON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONERS
On Behalf Of	Florida Defense Lawyers Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-02-28
Type	Brief
Subtype	Appendix-Juris
Description	APPENDIX-JURIS BRIEF ~ APPENDIX TO PETITIONERS' BRIEF ON JURISDICTION
On Behalf Of	University of Florida Board of Trustees
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-01-25
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Juris Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (JURIS BRIEF-PETITIONER) ~ Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted, and petitioner is allowed to and including February 28, 2022, in which to serve the brief on jurisdiction. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied. All other times will be extended accordingly
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-01-24
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Juris Brief)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (JURIS BRIEF) ~ UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME
On Behalf Of	University of Florida Board of Trustees
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-01-18
Type	Event
Subtype	Fee Paid Through Portal
Description	Fee Paid Through Portal

Docket Date	2022-01-14
Type	Notice
Subtype	Invoke Discretionary Jurisdiction
Description	NOTICE-DISCRETIONARY JURIS (CERT DIRECT CONFLICT)
On Behalf Of	University of Florida Board of Trustees
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-01-14
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Fee Status
Description	FP:Fee Paid Through Portal

Docket Date	2022-01-14
Type	Miscellaneous Document
Subtype	Pay Case Filing Fee-300
Description	PAY CASE FILING FEE-300
On Behalf Of	University of Florida Board of Trustees
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-01-14
Type	Letter-Case
Subtype	Acknowledgment Letter-New Case-Pay Fee
Description	ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER-NEW CASE-PAY FEE
View	View File

WILLIAM BOYLE VS MYLES RUBIN SAMOTIN, M.D., ET AL.

SC2020-1399

2020-09-24

Closed

Classification	Discretionary Review - Notice to Invoke - Certified Direct Conflict
Court	Supreme Court of Florida
Originating Court	Circuit Court for the Twentieth Judicial Circuit, Collier County 2D18-2932 Circuit Court for the Twentieth Judicial Circuit, Collier County 112016CA0023080001XX

Parties

Name	WILLIAM BOYLE, INC.
Role	Petitioner
Status	Active
Representations	Landis V. Curry III, J. Scott Murphy

Name	Myles Rubin Samotin, M.D.
Role	Respondent
Status	Active
Representations	Kirsten K. Ullman, Brian M. Bursa

Name	MYLES RUBIN SAMOTIN, M.D., P.A.
Role	Respondent
Status	Active

Name	Samotin Orthopaedics
Role	Respondent
Status	Active

Name	FLORIDA DEFENSE LAWYERS ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Amicus - Respondent
Status	Active
Representations	Kansas R. Gooden

Name	FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Amicus - Respondent
Status	Active
Representations	Mr. Andrew S. Bolin

Name	FLORIDA MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Amicus - Respondent
Status	Active

Name	Hon. Lauren L. Brodie
Role	Judge/Judicial Officer
Status	Active

Name	Hon. Mary Beth Kuenzel
Role	Lower Tribunal Clerk
Status	Active

Name	Hon. Crystal K. Kinzel
Role	Lower Tribunal Clerk
Status	Active

Docket Entries

Docket Date	2022-05-12
Type	Mandate
Subtype	Mandate Issued
Description	MANDATE

Docket Date	2022-05-12
Type	Miscellaneous Document
Subtype	Publish Full
Description	PUBLISH FULL
View	View File

Docket Date	2022-04-21
Type	Disposition
Subtype	Quashed
Description	DISP-QUASHED ~ FSC-OPINION: We hold that under section 766.106, Florida Statutes (2018), and Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.650, it is the timely mailing of the presuit notice of intent to initiate litigation, not the receipt of the notice, that begins the tolling of the applicable limitations period for filing a complaint for medical negligence. Accordingly, we quash the Second District's decision in Boyle, and we approve the certified conflict cases of Zacker and Baxter to the extent they are consistent with this opinion. It is so ordered.
View	View File

Docket Date	2021-03-24
Type	Brief
Subtype	Reply-Merit
Description	REPLY BRIEF-MERITS
On Behalf Of	William Boyle
View	View File

Docket Date	2021-03-17
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted and petitioner is allowed to and including March 29, 2021, in which to serve the reply brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.

Docket Date	2021-03-17
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Reply Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Petitioner's Unopposed Motion for Extensionof Time to Serve Reply Brief on the Merits
On Behalf Of	William Boyle
View	View File

Docket Date	2021-03-02
Type	Order
Subtype	Brief Stricken
Description	ORDER-BRIEF STRICKEN ~ In light of the filing of amici curiae Florida Hospital Association and Florida Medical Association's amended brief filed with this Court on March 2, 2021, it is ordered that Florida Hospital Association and Florida Medical Association's brief filed with this Court on March 1, 2021, is hereby stricken.

Docket Date	2021-03-02
Type	Brief
Subtype	Amicus Curiae Initial (Amended)
Description	AMICUS CURIAE INITIAL AMD BRIEF-MERITS ~ Amicus Curiae Brief of the Florida Hospital Association and Florida Medical Association
On Behalf Of	Florida Hospital Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2021-03-01
Type	Brief
Subtype	Amicus Curiae Initial
Description	AMICUS CURIAE INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS ~ Amicus Curiae Brief of the Florida Hospital Association and Florida Medical Association Does not contain Certificate of Compliance - Stricken 3/2/21, in light of amended brief filed.
On Behalf Of	Florida Hospital Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2021-02-18
Type	Brief
Subtype	Answer-Merit
Description	ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS
On Behalf Of	Myles Rubin Samotin, M.D.
View	View File

Docket Date	2021-02-08
Type	Notice
Subtype	Appearance
Description	NOTICE-APPEARANCE
On Behalf Of	Myles Rubin Samotin, M.D.
View	View File

Docket Date	2021-01-19
Type	Brief
Subtype	Initial-Merit
Description	INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS
On Behalf Of	William Boyle
View	View File

Docket Date	2021-01-08
Type	Record
Subtype	Record/Transcript
Description	RECORD ~ 1 VOLUME RECORD ON APPEAL (VOLUME 1) - Filed Electronically
On Behalf Of	Hon. Mary Beth Kuenzel

Docket Date	2021-01-07
Type	Order
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR ~ The motion for leave to file brief as amicus curiae filed by Florida Defense Lawyers Association is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of respondents. The brief by the above referenced amicus curiae shall be served pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.370(c).

Docket Date	2021-01-06
Type	Order
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR ~ The motion for leave to file brief as amicus curiae filed by Florida Hospital Association, and Florida Medical Association, is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of respondents. The brief by the above referenced amicus curiae shall be served pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.370(c).

Docket Date	2021-01-06
Type	Motion
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE
On Behalf Of	Florida Defense Lawyers Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2021-01-05
Type	Motion
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE
On Behalf Of	Florida Hospital Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2020-12-14
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Initial Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS)
On Behalf Of	William Boyle
View	View File

Docket Date	2020-12-14
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted and petitioner is allowed to and including January 19, 2021, in which to serve the initial brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.All other times will be extended accordingly.

Docket Date	2020-12-08
Type	Order
Subtype	No Req & Brief Sched/Juris Accepted
Description	ORDER-NO REQ&BRIEF SCHED/JURIS ACCEPTED ~ The Court accepts jurisdiction.Petitioner's brief on the merits shall be served on or before December 28, 2020; respondent's brief on the merits shall be served thirty days after service of petitioner's brief on the merits; and petitioner's reply brief on the merits shall be served thirty days after service of respondent's brief on the merits.The Clerk of the Second District Court of Appeal shall file the record which shall be properly indexed and paginated on or before February 8, 2021. The Clerk may provide the record in the format as currently maintained at the district court, either paper or electronic. The Court dispenses with oral argument pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.320.

Docket Date	2020-11-02
Type	Order
Subtype	Brief Non-Filing (Answer Brief)
Description	ORDER-BRIEF NON-FILING (ANSWER BRIEF) ~ Counsel for respondent having not filed an answer brief, the above case has been submitted to the Court for consideration.

Docket Date	2020-10-14
Type	Order
Subtype	Vacate
Description	ORDER-VACATE ~ The order of this Court dated October 8, 2020, directing the petitioner to submit the filing fee, or an order of insolvency, or a proper motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis, is hereby vacated. The filing fee was received by the Second District Court of Appeal on September 25, 2020.

Docket Date	2020-10-08
Type	Order
Subtype	Filing Fee Due
Description	ORDER-FILING FEE DUE ~ The jurisdiction of this Court was invoked by the filing of a Notice to Invoke Discretionary Jurisdiction in the lower tribunal; however, said notice was not accompanied by the $300.00 filing fee or an order of insolvency from the district court of appeal as required by Florida Rules of Appellate Procedure 9.110(b) and 9.120(b). The filing fee is due and payable at the time of filing the notice. Petitioner is allowed to and including November 9, 2020, in which to submit the filing fee, or an order of insolvency, or a proper motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis that complies with sections 57.081 and 57.082, Florida Statutes (2013). Failure to submit the filing fee or one of the above referenced documents to this Court could result in the imposition of sanctions, including dismissal of the notice.Please understand that once this case is dismissed, it is not subject to reinstatement. (10/14/20 VACATED)

Docket Date	2020-09-30
Type	Brief
Subtype	Juris Initial
Description	JURIS INITIAL BRIEF
On Behalf Of	William Boyle
View	View File

Docket Date	2020-09-25
Type	Event
Subtype	Fee Transferred From L.T.
Description	Fee Transferred From L.T.

Docket Date	2020-09-24
Type	Letter-Case
Subtype	Acknowledgment Letter-New Case-Pay Fee
Description	ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER-NEW CASE-PAY FEE

Docket Date	2020-09-24
Type	Notice
Subtype	Invoke Discretionary Jurisdiction
Description	NOTICE-DISCRETIONARY JURIS (CERT DIRECT CONFLICT)
On Behalf Of	William Boyle
View	View File

Docket Date	2020-09-24
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Fee Status
Description	PT:Fee Transferred From L.T.

GUILLERMO TABRAUE III, ETC. VS DOCTORS HOSPITAL, INC., ET AL.

SC2019-0685

2019-04-24

Closed

Classification	Discretionary Review - Notice to Invoke - Certified Direct Conflict
Court	Supreme Court of Florida
Originating Court	Circuit Court for the Eleventh Judicial Circuit, Miami-Dade County 132014CA002006000001 Circuit Court for the Eleventh Judicial Circuit, Miami-Dade County 3D16-1661

Parties

Name	Guillermo Tabraue III
Role	Petitioner
Status	Active
Representations	Meredith Ross, Bryan S. Gowdy, Jorge Silva

Name	Estate of Suyima Torres
Role	Petitioner
Status	Active

Name	Yasser Asmar, M.D., P.A.
Role	Respondent
Status	Active

Name	Pulmonary Physicians of South Florida, LLC
Role	Respondent
Status	Active
Representations	KEVIN P. O'CONNOR

Name	Joseph P. Bowers
Role	Respondent
Status	Active
Representations	Mr. Norman M. Waas

Name	FLORIDA DEFENSE LAWYERS ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Respondent
Status	Active
Representations	Kansas R. Gooden

Name	E.R. State, Inc.
Role	Respondent
Status	Active

Name	DOCTORS HOSPITAL, INC.
Role	Respondent
Status	Active
Representations	Michael R. D'Lugo, Jessica L. Gross

Name	Brenda Gonzalez, M.D.
Role	Respondent
Status	Active

Name	AARP INC.
Role	Amicus - Petitioner
Status	Active
Representations	M. Geron Gadd

Name	Arthur S. Shorr
Role	Amicus - Petitioner
Status	Active
Representations	Mr. Thomas S. Edwards Jr.

Name	Dr. Kayur V. Patel
Role	Amicus - Petitioner
Status	Active
Representations	Mr. Thomas S. Edwards Jr.

Name	FLORIDA JUSTICE ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Amicus - Petitioner
Status	Active
Representations	Andrew A. Harris, Adam Richardson

Name	FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Amicus - Respondent
Status	Active
Representations	Mr. Andrew S. Bolin

Name	Hon. Eric William Hendon
Role	Judge/Judicial Officer
Status	Active

Name	Hon. Harvey Ruvin
Role	Lower Tribunal Clerk
Status	Active

Name	Hon. Mercedes M. Prieto
Role	Lower Tribunal Clerk
Status	Active

Docket Entries

Docket Date	2020-04-09
Type	Disposition
Subtype	Dism Voluntary
Description	DISP-DISMISSED-VOLUNTARY ~ Petitioner having filed a proper notice of dismissal pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.350(b), it is ordered that the petition for review is hereby voluntarily dismissed.

Docket Date	2020-04-06
Type	Motion
Subtype	Notice-Dismiss (Voluntary)
Description	NOTICE-DISMISS (VOLUNTARY) ~ PETITIONER'S NOTICE OF VOLUNTARY DISMISSAL
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

Docket Date	2020-03-19
Type	Order
Subtype	OA Schedule (Prev Accepted)
Description	ORDER-OA SCHED (PREV ACCEPTED) ~ The Court previously accepted jurisdiction. The Court will hear oral argument at 9:00 a.m., Thursday, June 4, 2020.A maximum of twenty minutes to the side is allowed for the argument, but counsel is expected to use only so much of that time as is necessary.NO CONTINUANCES WILL BE GRANTED EXCEPT UPON A SHOWING OF EXTREME HARDSHIP.

Docket Date	2020-03-17
Type	Motion
Subtype	Request-Oral Argument
Description	REQUEST-ORAL ARGUMENT ~ PETITIONER'S REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

Docket Date	2020-03-12
Type	Notice
Subtype	Supplemental Authority
Description	NOTICE-SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY ~ PETITIONER'S NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

Docket Date	2020-03-11
Type	Brief
Subtype	Appendix-Merit
Description	APPENDIX-MERIT BRIEF ~ Petitioner's Supplemental Appendix
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

Docket Date	2020-02-05
Type	Brief
Subtype	Amicus Curiae Answer
Description	AMICUS CURIAE ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS ~ Amicus Curiae of Florida Defense Lawyers Association in Support of Respondents
On Behalf Of	Florida Defense Lawyers Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2020-02-04
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted and petitioner is allowed to and including March 11, 2020, in which to serve the reply brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.

Docket Date	2020-02-04
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Reply Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS) ~ PETITIONER'S UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO SERVE REPLY BRIEF
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

Docket Date	2020-02-03
Type	Brief
Subtype	Amicus Curiae Answer
Description	AMICUS CURIAE ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS ~ Amicus Curiae Brief of the Florida Hospital Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2020-01-24
Type	Brief
Subtype	Answer-Merit
Description	ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS ~ Brief of Respondent
On Behalf Of	Doctors Hospital, Inc.
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-11-26
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Respondent's motion for extension of time is granted, and respondent is allowed to and including January 24, 2020, in which to serve the answer brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.All other times will be extended accordingly.

Docket Date	2019-11-25
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Answer Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time for Respondent to Serve Answer Brief
On Behalf Of	Doctors Hospital, Inc.
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-11-07
Type	Order
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR ~ The motion for leave to file brief as amicus curiae filed by Florida Justice Association is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of Petitioner. The brief by the above referenced amicus curiae was filed with this Court on November 6, 2019.

Docket Date	2019-11-06
Type	Brief
Subtype	Amicus Curiae Initial
Description	AMICUS CURIAE INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS ~ BRIEF OF AMICUS CURIAE FLORIDA JUSTICE ASSOCIATION INSUPPORT OF PETITIONER
On Behalf Of	Florida Justice Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-10-04
Type	Order
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR ~ The motion for leave to file brief as amicus curiae filed by AARP and AARP Foundation is hereby granted. The brief by the above referenced amicus curiae shall be served pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.370(c).

Docket Date	2019-11-06
Type	Motion
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE ~ MOTION OF FLORIDA JUSTICE ASSOCIATION FOR LEAVE TO FILEAN AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONER
On Behalf Of	Florida Justice Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-11-06
Type	Order
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR ~ The motion for leave to file brief as amicus curiae filed by Dr. Kayur V. Patel and Arthur S. Shorr is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of Petitioner. The brief by the above referenced amici curiae shall be served pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.370(c).

Docket Date	2019-11-05
Type	Motion
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE ~ UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR LEAVE TO APPEARAS AMICUS CURIAE OFKAYUR V. PATEL, M.D., MRO, FACP, FACPE, FACHE, FACEPANDARTHUR S. SHORR, L-FACHEIN SUPPORT OF PETITIONER
On Behalf Of	Dr. Kayur V. Patel
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-11-04
Type	Brief
Subtype	Amicus Curiae Initial
Description	AMICUS CURIAE INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS ~ BRIEF OF AMICI CURIAE AARP AND AARP FOUNDATIONIN SUPPORT OF PETITIONER
On Behalf Of	AARP
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-10-25
Type	Brief
Subtype	Initial-Merit
Description	INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS ~ INITIAL BRIEF OF PETITIONER
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-10-22
Type	Order
Subtype	Brief Enlargement
Description	ORDER-BRIEF PAGE ENLARGEMENT GR ~ Petitioner's Motion to File Initial Brief in Excess of 50-Page Limitation is hereby granted.

Docket Date	2019-10-21
Type	Motion
Subtype	Toll Time
Description	MOTION-TOLL TIME ~ PETITIONER'S MOTION TO TOLL TIME
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-10-07
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted and petitioner is allowed to and including October 21, 2019, in which to serve the initial brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.All other times will be extended accordingly.

Docket Date	2019-10-07
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Initial Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS) ~ PETITIONER'S UNOPPOSED MOTION FOREXTENSION OF TIME TO SERVE INITIAL BRIEF
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-10-03
Type	Motion
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE ~ UNOPPOSED MOTION OF AARP AND AARP FOUNDATIONFOR LEAVE TO PARTICIPATE AS AMICI CURIAE
On Behalf Of	AARP
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-09-11
Type	Order
Subtype	Recusal
Description	ORDER-RECUSAL ~ On her own initiative, Honorable Barbara Lagoa exercises her authority pursuant to Florida Rule of Judicial Administration 2.330(i) to order her disqualification from this case.

Docket Date	2019-08-26
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Initial Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS) ~ PETITIONER'S UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO SERVE INITIAL BRIEF
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-08-26
Type	Record
Subtype	Record/Transcript
Description	RECORD ~ ORIGINAL RECORD ON APPEALFROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OFMIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
On Behalf Of	Hon. Mercedes M. Prieto

Docket Date	2019-08-26
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted and petitioner is allowed to and including October 14, 2019, in which to serve the initial brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.All other times will be extended accordingly.

Docket Date	2019-08-02
Type	Order
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR ~ The motion for leave to file brief as amicus curiae filed by Florida Defense Lawyers Association is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of respondents. The brief by the above referenced amicus curiae shall be served pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.370(c).

Docket Date	2019-08-01
Type	Motion
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE ~ FLORIDA DEFENSE LAWYERS ASSOCIATION'SMOTION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAR AS AMICUS CURIAEON BEHALF OF RESPONDENTS
On Behalf Of	Florida Defense Lawyers Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-07-30
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted and petitioner is allowed to and including September 12, 2019, in which to serve the initial brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.All other times will be extended accordingly.

Docket Date	2019-07-26
Type	Notice
Subtype	Appearance
Description	NOTICE-APPEARANCE ~ NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AND DESIGNATION OF EMAIL ADDRESSES
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-07-26
Type	Order
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR ~ The motion for leave to file brief as amicus curiae filed by Florida Hospital Association is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of respondents. The brief by the above referenced amicus curiae shall be served pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.370(c).

Docket Date	2019-07-26
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Initial Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS) ~ PETITIONER'S UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO SERVE INITIAL BRIEF
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-07-25
Type	Motion
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE ~ MOTION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAR AS AMICUS CURIAEIN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS
On Behalf Of	Florida Hospital Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-07-24
Type	Order
Subtype	Juris Accept/Brief Sched (OA Later Date)
Description	ORDER-JURIS ACCEPT/BRIEF SCHED (OA LATER DATE) ~ The Court accepts jurisdiction of this case. Petitioner's initial brief on the merits must be served on or before August 13, 2019; respondent's answer brief on the merits must be served thirty days after service of petitioner's initial brief on the merits; and petitioner's reply brief on the merits must be served thirty days after service of respondent's answer brief on the merits.The Clerk of the Third District Court of Appeal must file the record which must be properly indexed and paginated on or before September 23, 2019. The Clerk may provide the record in the format as currently maintained at the district court, either paper or electronic.Oral argument will be set by separate order. Counsel for the parties will be notified of the oral argument date approximately sixty days prior to oral argument.

Docket Date	2019-06-19
Type	Order
Subtype	Brief Non-Filing (Answer Brief)
Description	ORDER-BRIEF NON-FILING (ANSWER BRIEF) ~ Counsel for respondents Joseph P. Bowers and Pulmonary Physicians of South Florida, LLC. having not filed answer briefs, the above case has been submitted to the Court for consideration.

Docket Date	2019-06-17
Type	Brief
Subtype	Juris Answer
Description	JURIS ANSWER BRIEF ~ JURISDICTIONAL BRIEF OF RESPONDENT
On Behalf Of	Doctors Hospital, Inc.
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-05-29
Type	Order
Subtype	Recusal
Description	ORDER-RECUSAL DY ~ The motion for recusal of the Honorable Barbara Lagoa and the Honorable Robert J. Luck filed by petitioner is hereby denied.

Docket Date	2019-05-17
Type	Brief
Subtype	Appendix-Juris
Description	APPENDIX-JURIS BRIEF ~ APPENDIX TO JURISDICTIONAL BRIEF OF PETITIONER
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-05-17
Type	Response
Subtype	Response
Description	RESPONSE ~ RESPONDENT'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO PETITIONER'SMOTION TO DISQUALIFY JUSTICES LAGOA AND LUCK
On Behalf Of	Doctors Hospital, Inc.
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-05-03
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Juris Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (JURIS BRIEF-PETITIONER) ~ Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted, and petitioner is allowed to and including May 17, 2019, in which to serve the brief on jurisdiction. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied. All other times will be extended accordingly.

Docket Date	2019-05-02
Type	Motion
Subtype	Toll Time
Description	MOTION-TOLL TIME ~ PETITIONER'S MOTION TO TOLL TIME
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

Docket Date	2019-04-30
Type	Event
Subtype	Fee Paid in Full - $300
Description	Fee Paid In Full - $300

Docket Date	2019-04-29
Type	Letter-Case
Subtype	Acknowledgment Letter-New Case-Pay Fee
Description	ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER-NEW CASE-PAY FEE

Docket Date	2019-04-24
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Fee Status
Description	A3:Paid In Full - $300

Docket Date	2019-04-24
Type	Notice
Subtype	Invoke Discretionary Jurisdiction
Description	NOTICE-DISCRETIONARY JURIS (CERT DIRECT CONFLICT)
On Behalf Of	Guillermo Tabraue III
View	View File

NORTH BROWARD HOSPITAL DISTRICT, ETC., ET AL. VS SUSAN KALITAN

SC2015-1858

2015-10-12

Closed

Classification	Mandatory Review - Notice of Appeal - Statutory/Constitutional Invalidity
Court	Supreme Court of Florida
Originating Court	Circuit Court for the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit, Broward County 4D11-4834 Circuit Court for the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit, Broward County 062008CA029706AXXXCE Circuit Court for the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit, Broward County 4D11-4806 Circuit Court for the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit, Broward County 4D11-4833

Parties

Name	EDWARD PUNZALAN, CRNA
Role	Appellant
Status	Active

Name	ROB ALEXANDER, M.D.
Role	Appellant
Status	Active

Name	D/B/A BROWARD GENERAL MEDICAL
Role	Appellant
Status	Active

Name	BARRY UNIVERSITY, INC.
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Thomas A. Valdez, Jeffrey R. Creasman

Name	NORTH BROWARD HOSPITAL DISTRICT
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Dinah Stein, Mark Hicks

Name	ELEIDY MIEDES, SRNA
Role	Appellant
Status	Active
Representations	Thomas A. Valdez, Jeffrey R. Creasman

Name	ANESCO NORTH BROWARD, LLC
Role	Appellant
Status	Active

Name	SUSAN KALITAN
Role	Appellee
Status	Active
Representations	Crane Johnstone, Philip M. Burlington, Nichole J. Segal, Scott P. Schlesinger

Name	FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Amicus - Petitioner
Status	Active
Representations	Mark K. Delegal, Tiffany A. Roddenberry

Name	STATE OF FLORIDA LLC
Role	Amicus - Petitioner
Status	Active
Representations	Mr. Osvaldo Vazquez, ALLEN WINSOR

Name	FLORIDA JUSTICE REFORM INSTITUTE, INC.
Role	Amicus - Petitioner
Status	Active
Representations	Mark K. Delegal, Tiffany A. Roddenberry, William W. Large

Name	FLORIDA JUSTICE ASSOCIATION, INC.
Role	Amicus - Respondent
Status	Active
Representations	TRACY RAFFLES GUNN

Name	Hon. Jack B. Tuter Jr.
Role	Judge/Judicial Officer
Status	Active

Name	Hon. Brenda D. Forman
Role	Lower Tribunal Clerk
Status	Active

Docket Entries

Docket Date	2016-05-25
Type	Order
Subtype	Case Style Change
Description	ORDER-CASE STYLE CHANGE ~ The style of the above case has been changed from North Broward Hospital District, etc., et al. vs. Susan Kalitan, et al. to North Broward Hospital District, etc., et al. vs. Susan Kalitan.

Docket Date	2017-07-11
Type	Record
Subtype	Record/Transcript Returned
Description	RECORD/TRANSCRIPT RETURNED ~ Contains 1 index of record, 1 Volume Certified Copies of Appeal Papers, 84 volumes of record, 2 boxes of exhibits (7 boxes total) (paper record returned to Fourth DCA)

Docket Date	2017-06-29
Type	Miscellaneous Document
Subtype	Publish Full
Description	PUBLISH FULL
View	View File

Docket Date	2017-06-29
Type	Mandate
Subtype	Mandate Issued
Description	MANDATE

Docket Date	2017-06-08
Type	Order
Subtype	Atty Fees DY (J/M/O)
Description	ORDER-ATTY FEES DY (J/M/O) ~ Appellant's motion for attorney's fees is hereby denied.

Docket Date	2017-06-08
Type	Disposition
Subtype	Affirmed/Remanded
Description	DISP-AFFIRMED/REMANDED ~ FSC-OPINION: Therefore, we hold that the caps on personal injury noneconomic damages provided in section 766.118 violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Florida Constitution. Accordingly, we affirm the Fourth District's decision, and remand to the district court for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.It is so ordered.
View	View File

Docket Date	2017-05-16
Type	Notice
Subtype	Unavailability
Description	NOTICE-UNAVAILABILITY
On Behalf Of	BARRY UNIVERSITY, INC.
View	View File

Docket Date	2016-12-28
Type	Notice
Subtype	Unavailability
Description	NOTICE-UNAVAILABILITY
On Behalf Of	ELEIDY MIEDES, SRNA
View	View File

Docket Date	2016-10-27
Type	Notice
Subtype	Supplemental Authority
Description	NOTICE-SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY ~ Authority not attached. Amended Notice of Supplemental Authority filed 10/27/2016.
On Behalf Of	SUSAN KALITAN
View	View File

Docket Date	2016-06-09
Type	Event
Subtype	Oral Argument Held
Description	ORAL ARGUMENT HELD

Docket Date	2016-06-03
Type	Notice
Subtype	Supplemental Authority
Description	NOTICE-SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY
On Behalf Of	SUSAN KALITAN
View	View File

Docket Date	2016-03-16
Type	Order
Subtype	OA Schedule
Description	ORDER-OA SCHED ~ The above case is hereby scheduled for oral argument at 9:00 a.m., Thursday, June 9, 2016. A maximum of twenty minutes to the side is allowed for the argument, but counsel is expected to use only so much of that time as is necessary.NO CONTINUANCES WILL BE GRANTED EXCEPT UPON A SHOWING OF EXTREME HARDSHIP.

Docket Date	2016-03-14
Type	Brief
Subtype	Reply-Merit
Description	REPLY BRIEF-MERITS
On Behalf Of	NORTH BROWARD HOSPITAL DISTRICT
View	View File

Docket Date	2016-03-14
Type	Notice
Subtype	Adoption
Description	NOTICE-ADOPTION ~ NOTICE OF ADOPTION OF CO-APPELLANTS' REPLY BRIEF ON THE MERITS
On Behalf Of	BARRY UNIVERSITY, INC.
View	View File

Docket Date	2016-03-11
Type	Motion
Subtype	Request-Oral Argument
Description	REQUEST-ORAL ARGUMENT
On Behalf Of	BARRY UNIVERSITY, INC.
View	View File

Docket Date	2016-03-11
Type	Response
Subtype	Response
Description	RESPONSE ~ FILED AS "NOTICE OF ADOPTION OF CO-PETITIONERS' RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO RESPONDENT'S MOTION FOR A CONDITIONAL AWARD OF APPELLATE ATTORNEY'S FEES"
On Behalf Of	BARRY UNIVERSITY, INC.
View	View File

Docket Date	2016-02-19
Type	Motion
Subtype	Toll Time
Description	MOTION-TOLL TIME ~ APPELLANTS' MOTION TO TOLL TIME
On Behalf Of	NORTH BROWARD HOSPITAL DISTRICT
View	View File

Docket Date	2016-02-19
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Appellants' Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Reply Brief is granted and appellants are allowed to and including March 14, 2016, in which to serve the reply brief on the merits. NO FURTHER EXTENSIONS OF TIME WILL BE GRANTED TO APPELLANTS FOR THE FILING OF THE REPLY BRIEF ON THE MERITS.

Docket Date	2016-02-10
Type	Response
Subtype	Response
Description	RESPONSE ~ PETITIONERS ANESCO NORTH BROWARD, LLCAND ROB ALEXANDER, M.D.'S RESPONSE INOPPOSITION TO RESPONDENT'S MOTION FOR ACONDITIONAL AWARD OF APPELLATE ATTORNEYS' FEES
On Behalf Of	NORTH BROWARD HOSPITAL DISTRICT
View	View File

Docket Date	2016-02-08
Type	Brief
Subtype	Amicus Curiae Initial
Description	AMICUS CURIAE INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS ~ AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF OF THE FLORIDA JUSTICE ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENT SUSAN KALITAN
On Behalf Of	Florida Justice Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2016-01-28
Type	Motion
Subtype	Attorney's Fees
Description	MOTION-ATTORNEYS FEES ~ RESPONDENT'S MOTION FOR A CONDITIONAL AWARD OF APPELLATE ATTORNEYS' FEES
On Behalf Of	SUSAN KALITAN
View	View File

Docket Date	2016-01-28
Type	Brief
Subtype	Answer-Merit
Description	ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS
On Behalf Of	SUSAN KALITAN
View	View File

Docket Date	2016-01-26
Type	Order
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR ~ The Agreed Motion for Leave to File an Amicus Curiae Brief in Support of the Respondent filed by the Florida Justice Association is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of appellee. The brief by the above referenced amicus curiae shall be served pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.370(c).

Docket Date	2016-01-26
Type	Motion
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE ~ AGREED MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AN AMICUS CURIAEBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF THE RESPONDENT (FJA)
On Behalf Of	Florida Justice Association
View	View File

Docket Date	2015-12-28
Type	Motion
Subtype	Ext of Time (Answer Brief-Merit)
Description	MOTION-EXT OF TIME (ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS) ~ UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR EXTENSION
On Behalf Of	SUSAN KALITAN
View	View File

Docket Date	2015-12-28
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Respondent's Unopposed Motion for Extension is granted, and respondent is allowed to and including January 28, 2016, in which to serve the answer brief on the merits. NO FURTHER EXTENSIONS OF TIME WILL BE GRANTED TO RESPONDENT FOR THE FILING OF THE ANSWER BRIEF ON THE MERITS. All other times will be extended accordingly.

Docket Date	2015-12-15
Type	Order
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR ~ The Motion for Leave to File a Brief as Amicus Curiae filed by the State of Florida is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of appellants. The brief by the above referenced amicus curiae was filed with this Court on December 14, 2015.

Docket Date	2015-12-14
Type	Brief
Subtype	Amicus Curiae Initial
Description	AMICUS CURIAE INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS ~ AMICUS BRIEF OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA IN SUPPORT OF APPELLANTS
On Behalf Of	State of Florida
View	View File

Docket Date	2015-12-14
Type	Motion
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE ~ ATTORNEY GENERAL'S UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE A BRIEF AS AMICUS CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF APPELLANTS
On Behalf Of	State of Florida
View	View File

Docket Date	2015-12-11
Type	Order
Subtype	Strike
Description	ORDER-STRIKE ~ Appellant's Notice of Adoption of Co-Appellants' Initial Brief on the Merits is hereby stricken until payment of fee due pursuant to Florida Statute 25.241(2)(b).VACATED 12/15/2015

Docket Date	2015-12-08
Type	Order
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR ~ The Motion for Leave of Court to File an Amicus Curiae Brief in Support of Petitioners filed by Florida Justice Reform Institute and Florida Hospital Association, Inc. is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of petitioner. The brief by the above referenced amici curiae shall be served pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.370(c).

Docket Date	2015-12-07
Type	Motion
Subtype	Amicus Curiae
Description	MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE ~ Motion for Leave of Court to File an Amicus Curiae Brief in Support of the Petitioners
On Behalf Of	Florida Justice Reform Institute
View	View File

Docket Date	2015-12-04
Type	Order
Subtype	Appendix Due
Description	ORDER-APPENDIX DUE ~ Petitioner's initial brief on the merits was filed with the Court on December 3, 2015, but not accompanied by an appendix pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.220. Petitioner is directed, on or before December 28, 2015, to serve an appendix. The appendix shall contain an index and a conformed copy of the opinion or order to be reviewed and may contain any other portions of the record and other authorities.

Docket Date	2015-12-04
Type	Brief
Subtype	Appendix-Merit
Description	APPENDIX-MERIT BRIEF ~ APPENDIX TO PETITIONERS' INITIAL BRIEF ON THE MERITS
On Behalf Of	NORTH BROWARD HOSPITAL DISTRICT
View	View File

Docket Date	2015-12-04
Type	Motion
Subtype	Attorney's Fees
Description	MOTION-ATTORNEYS FEES ~ APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR A CONDITIONALAWARD OF APPELLATE ATTORNEY'S FEES
On Behalf Of	NORTH BROWARD HOSPITAL DISTRICT
View	View File

Docket Date	2015-12-03
Type	Brief
Subtype	Initial-Merit
Description	INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS
On Behalf Of	NORTH BROWARD HOSPITAL DISTRICT
View	View File

Docket Date	2015-12-03
Type	Notice
Subtype	Adoption
Description	NOTICE-ADOPTION ~ Filed as NOTICE OF ADOPTION OF CO-APPELLANTS' INITIAL BRIEF ON THE MERITS
On Behalf Of	ELEIDY MIEDES, SRNA
View	View File

Docket Date	2015-12-03
Type	Motion
Subtype	Request-Oral Argument
Description	REQUEST-ORAL ARGUMENT
On Behalf Of	NORTH BROWARD HOSPITAL DISTRICT
View	View File

Docket Date	2015-11-13
Type	Record
Subtype	Record/Transcript
Description	RECORD/TRANSCRIPT ~ Contains 1 index of record, 1 Volume Certified Copies of Appeal Papers, 84 volumes of record, 2 boxes of exhibits (7 boxes total) (paper record filed)

Docket Date	2015-11-06
Type	Record
Subtype	Record/Transcript
Description	RECORD ~ CERTIFIED COPIES OF APPEAL PAPERS (FILED ELECTRONICALLY)

Docket Date	2015-11-03
Type	Order
Subtype	Extension of Time (Merits Brief)
Description	ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS) ~ Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted, and petitioner is allowed to and including December 3, 2015, in which to serve the initial brief on the merits. NO FURTHER EXTENSIONS OF TIME WILL BE GRANTED TO PETITIONER FOR THE FILING OF THE INITIAL BRIEF ON THE MERITS. All other times will be extended accordingly.

Docket Date	2015-11-02
Type	Motion
Subtype	Toll Time
Description	MOTION-TOLL TIME ~ APPELLANTS' MOTION TO TOLL TIME
On Behalf Of	NORTH BROWARD HOSPITAL DISTRICT
View	View File

Docket Date	2015-10-22
Type	Event
Subtype	Fee Due, but not billed
Description	Fee Due, but not billed ~ $295 Notice of Joinder fee due before initial brief on the merits
On Behalf Of	BARRY UNIVERSITY, INC.

Docket Date	2015-10-20
Type	Notice
Subtype	Joinder
Description	NOTICE-JOINDER ~ FILED AS "NOTICE OF JOINDER IN CO-APPELLANTS'/CO-CROSS APPELLEES'APPEAL TO FLORIDA SUPREME COURT"
On Behalf Of	BARRY UNIVERSITY, INC.
View	View File

Docket Date	2015-10-13
Type	Event
Subtype	Fee Paid in Full - $300
Description	Fee Paid In Full - $300

Docket Date	2015-10-13
Type	Letter-Case
Subtype	Acknowledgment Letter-New Case
Description	ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER-NEW CASE

Docket Date	2015-10-12
Type	Notice
Subtype	Appeal
Description	NOTICE-APPEAL (STAT/CONST INVALID)
On Behalf Of	NORTH BROWARD HOSPITAL DISTRICT
View	View File

Docket Date	2015-10-12
Type	Misc. Events
Subtype	Fee Status
Description	A3:Paid In Full - $300

Date of last update: 01 Feb 2025

Sources: Florida Department of State

FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, INC.

Company Details

form 5500

Agent

Boar

Vice Chairman

Treasurer

Chief Financial Officer

Secretary

President

Events

Court Cases

Related by officers

Related by address